Friday, July 08, 2005

Business as Usual

The G8 summit has concluded.
"The people have roared but the G8 has whispered," said Kumi Naidoo, chair of the Global Call to Action against Poverty.
Some progess has been made but not nearly enough. The next key prospect for progress is in December at the World Trade Organisation.
Mr Blair said trade discussions in Hong Kong later this year should yield an end date to agricultural subsidies.
These agricultural subsidies are a huge barrier to development in many poor countries. As I see it, the left and the right are agreed that they should be scrapped. Public pressure must continue if real progress is to be made.

The BBC has also put the G8 Gleneagles Communique online (pdf). I've not had a chance to look at it yet. Just flagging that it's there.

Blatant Soliciting

The Incitement to Religious Hatred bill goes to the vote on Monday. I'd like to let my MP know what people think about this bill. Your participation is humbly requested.

Thursday, July 07, 2005

I didn't vote for her

Is this the most idiotic statement in the history of the "war" on terror? Leader of the House of Lords Baroness Amos, on Question Time, rejected Morgan Tsvangirai's suggestion that international terrorism is unacceptable but that it should be fought partly by dealing with the wider global issues. Apparently this isn't possible because there are no ideological motives behind these new international terrorist activities.
"We are dealing with terrorism, pure and simple."
It's just so bad I'm struggling to compose my thoughts. Ffs, this is a Cabinet minister saying this. Please tell me this isn't government policy.
Anyway, there's a post about terrorism brewing at the moment. I think I have a title.

It's not the first time Baroness Amos has shocked me though. I remember an appearance on Newnight back when reporters were still asking when we were going to find all those WMD in Iraq (I think about six months after "major combat operations ended"). When pressed, the Baroness said that what with keeping order, and feeding the population, and restoring electritity supplies, and what not, the search for WMD were no longer a priority.

No longer a priority? Tons and tons of poison gases, anthrax, radioactive materials and god knows what else.
It seemed an absolutely extraordinary statement at the time and I still don't understand it.

*Straps on TinFoil Hat*
It occured to me that the statement only made sense if she knew something we didn't.
*Removes TinFoil Hat*

I suspect that she just wasn't making sense. It's a suprisingly easy thing to do.

Bombs in London

BBC report.
Bloggerheads.
Europhobia.
Guardian News Blog.
Flickr Photostream.

An al-Quaida-related organisation has claimed responsibility.

Update
BBC report.
UK Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said the bombings had "the hallmarks of an al-Qaeda-related attack".
Reading around a few blogs, it looks like Londoners have reacted in true British fashion with a "fuck you Mr Terrorist", and have tried to keep things as normal as possible. Lots of people seem to have gone down the pub. In fact, perfect spots a meme. I'm not from London but it seems appropriate:

London Pride

Too right.

Lost is Lost

Anyone know what's happened to Lost in Westminster?
Doctorvee wants to know too.
Could it be another Whitehall whitewash?

Anyway, I hope he's not in trouble or anything.

There's danger on the edge of town

The Scottish Sun have a photo of a chinook helicopter on the front page today (not online, but in England they're still going on about some game they've won or something). The helicopter was used yesterday to transport police reinforcements to trouble spots around Gleaneagles. I've said it before, but I don't think this sort of violent direct action is useful here.

Anyway, the S.Sun provides an example of what I mean. The photo of the military helicopter isn't enough, more propaganda is required. Gordon Brewer reported on Newsnight Scotland that the accompanying S.Sun article refered to yesterday's violence at Gleneagles and drew comparisions with the Vietnam War (military helicopter = Vietnam connection, y'see).

Update

I've seen the front page of todays Scottish Sun and there are not one but two references to Vietnam. These are from memory, as I obviously didn't buy it.
Byline (or sub headline or whatever it's called): 'Vietnam' airlift for Police...
Article: In scenes reminiscent of Vietnam...
Update ends.

Yes, the Vietnam War, in which millions of South-East Asians were killed. (The figures are disputed but then we all know how careful the US military gets when it comes to counting civilian casualties. We do know that 58,226 US military personel were killed.)

Yes, the Vietnam War, in which US troops murdered 300 - 500 unarmed civilians at My Lai. Here's a photo of the aftermath of that massacre.

Yes, the Vietnam War photographed here, and here, and here, and here.

Yes, the Vietnam War, with the faulty exit strategy:
The goal was to gradually build up the South Vietnamese Army so that it could fight the war on its own. This policy became the cornerstone of the so-called "Nixon Doctrine". As applied to Vietnam, the doctrine was called "Vietnamization". The stated goal of Vietnamization was to enable the South Vietnamese army to increasingly hold its own against the NLF and the North Vietnamese Army. The unstated goal of Vietnamization was that the primary burden of combat would be returned to ARVN troops and thereby lessen domestic opposition to the war in the U.S.
That sounds strangely familiar.

Anyway, the Vietnam War is what the S.Sun is apparently comparing yesterday's disturbances to.

Yesterday, less than 200 people were arrested. 29 policemen were injured, none of them seriously. No-one was napalmed.

Wednesday, July 06, 2005

Shrub Crash

Lot's of serious stuff going on today.

On the other hand...
Before attending the banquet, President Bush received treatment for minor injuries sustained when he collided with a police officer during a bike ride around the Gleneagles estate.
You know, falling off your bike is a bit like learning to ride a bike. Once you know how, you never forget. Perhaps an alternative form of two wheeled transport is in order.
Then again, perhaps not.

Update: Tim has more.

Big John

It's not often these days that our great leader allows his deputy out on his own. Due to Tony's very busy schedule (saving the world and organising games and stuff), Prescott has had to take DPMQs. I recommend watching the video to fully appreciate the DPMs performance. Given my problems with language, perhaps I shouldn't comment but, I mean, is he really second in charge of the country? It's like listening to an accident. You know you shouldn't, but somehow you just can't tear yourself away.
My highlight:
...but it is, I think, of great importance to all of us to see the maximization of people voting on these issues is increased...
Crystal.
Someone at Hansard's going to have to transcribe the whole thing.
I'm sure I speak for everyone when I say that I hope there is some sort of fiscal renumeration in the form of a Prescott Bonus paid to the employee of Hansard who has to undertake so difficult a task as this within the time frame specified by his or her employer and by society as a whole so as to provide the valuable public service that New Labour has introduced and which has improved two and a half thousand percent since the Conservative...

Fair and Balanced

The Scotsman has a splendid front page today.
Stay in your home!

As the small caption at the bottom says, this is a photo of Darfur survivors burning a replica hut in protest at the international community's lack of action. The accompanying article, headlined Battle lines drawn for Gleneagles siege: G8 protestors pledge blockade as leaders arrive for summit, doesn't actually refer to this protest. Neither do pages 2 - 7. In fact, it appears you've got to go back to May 3rd to find reference to Darfur in a Scotsman article.
It is an ecovative image though.

(Not stricly related but it turns out that I've not been able to attend any of the protests. I have a lame excuse but it's a bit long winded. It's also all about me. As such, I'll leave it for the weekend. As a few kind readers may know, I tend to ramble on then anyway.)

Going for Gold

London is to host the Olympic Games in 2012. Forgive me if I don't jump for joy but from where I live, London is just as far away as Paris. Quite a surprise though.

Btw, Tony Blair lobbying in Singapore in the run up to the G8 summit? Public relations opportunity or hard work behind the scenes to save lives and the planet?

It's only a game Tony. The clue's in the name.

Update
From the above, people might think I wanted Paris to win. I should clarify. I'm pretty ambivalent about this one way or the other.

David Beckham reacts to the news on BBC News 24:
"It's hard to put into words."
Quite.

John Sopel in Paris
The stage that was supposed to play out the celebratory party is being dsismantled. It was a surreal moment of shock when the result came through and while most people have left there has been a gaggle of people locked in an argument ever since. Was it all politics, were there other issues and they're trying to explain conspiracy theories to each other. When Trafalgar Square was shown on the big screen everyone started booing and it's hard to broadcast as people left outside the Hotel de Ville are very upset.
This, just before he was drowned out by a booing French mob. Not long after, cut to crowd in Trafalgar Square chanting "Are you watching, Jacques Chiraq?"
A worthy tribute to Nelson, I'm sure you'll agree.

More French updates
Guido is in Paris and provides this photo for our amusement. You know, that really shouldn't be funny, and yet...
Also in Paris is Katie, with news of the French shrug.

Right, who thinks there'll be something unsavoury being announced by the government right now? I'm off to see if I can find out.

Tuesday, July 05, 2005

Destined for Greatness

Justin at Chicken Yoghurt has all you need to know about the G8 Justice League. Read it. That is all.

Lackey Overload

There was a discussion on The World at One today about how the government appoints chairmen to the Commons select committees (starts 24 minutes in, online till lunchtime tomorrow). Ian Gibson has lost his place as chair of the Science and Technology committee. He believes that this might be due to his criticisms of the government. Given that select committes are intended to allow backbenchers to hold the government to account, this seems more than a little odd. Criticism is, after all, part of the job.

Perhaps Ian is being overly paraniod, as he himself suggests might be the case. Well, because these appointments are agreed behind closed doors, there is no way to say for sure. What it is possible to do, courtesy of theyworkforyou, is examine the voting record of those that will chair the committees.
The government's nominees are here.

Health - Kevin Barron
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Home affairs - John Denham
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Education and skills - Barry Sheerman
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Foreign affairs - Mike Gapes
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Transport - Gwyneth Dunwoody
Quite often rebels
(Analysis)

Work and Pensions - Terry Rooney
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister - Phyillis Starkey
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Wales - Hywel Francis
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Human rights - Andrew Dismore
Never rebels
(Analysis)

Rgulatory Reform - Andrew Miller
Never rebels
(Analysis)

That's the lot. Only one of the chairmen, Gwyneth Dunwoody, shows any sign of independent thought, and she had to fight to keep her position. Poor Ian Gibson sometimes rebels. He's out on his ear.

This is a perfect example of what is known in Number 10 as the LRC strategy (Listening and Responding to Concerns). It's apparently very effective.

News That Matters

This, from page 3 of the Press and Journal.
A New Look For Historic Torry Foghorn

Yes, the defunct foghorn has been painted. It's had three undercoats and a topcoat. I'm sure we'll all sleep safer in our beds...

Nostalgia Alert: Cheap shots aside, I'm actually glad the foghorn hasn't been demolished. I remember my Grandad telling me about the time he'd been deafened while walking past when it had sounded. As kids, we used to cycle up there just in case it went off when we were nearby. Sadly, it never did but we'd always visit one more time, just in case we got lucky.

The story also shows that Aberdeen City Council have a sense of humour. Well I never, who would have thunk it?
The Northern Lighthouse Board said in 2003 that the foghorn should be removed, partly because it had become a place for "insalubrious groups".
That argument was ridiculed by Aberdeen City Council, which claimed that such logic would lead to the demolition of all city shopping centres.
Most amusing. Well done those elected representatives.

Vote Damn It!

Geoff Hoon. Idiot.
People could face fines if they fail to vote in British general elections, under plans outlined by Geoff Hoon. The Commons leader says a move towards compulsory voting is necessary to reinvigorate UK democracy.
The Independent points out that he didn't rule out electoral reform for the Commons in his speech. This is the tiny redeeming feature which means I'm only going as far as to say he's an idiot.
Mr Hoon blamed a sense of "alienation" from the political system among people who felt that voting made no difference, a trend that would be exacerbated as the parties increasingly tailored their policies to people they knew would vote.
Astonishing really. Idiot.
He is expected to say that the 61 per cent turnout in May’s general election left him “more concerned about our democracy than ever before”
Remarkable. (I'm impressed by the way the Times can quote from speech that hadn't yet been given but that's neither here nor there.)
Idiot.
"A higher turnout is vital if we are to ensure a representative, healthy and vibrant democracy in our country. International experience points to compulsory voting being the most effective way to increase turnout."
You couldn't make it up. Geoff, if only you were to read this, I could help steer you towards the problem with democracy in our country. All you need to do is gather together all the New Labour spinmeisters, and your boss, and your cabinet colleagues, and think about the title of the newspaper in that last link.
Idiots.

Monday, July 04, 2005

A bit more Live 8

The BBC has received around 400 complaints about swearing during Live 8. Mediawatchwatch has the link. I don't often swear here for various reasons, but I'm going to now. Fuck off! Don't these people have anything better to do? How about complaining about the fact that so many people die early and needlessly in impoverished countries? Fucking narrow minded idiots!

Anyway, one of the critisisms of Live 8 was that those appearing would also boost their CD sales.
The same BBC link has a wee chart showing the top 10 beneficiaries and the percentage increases in sales since their appearances.

1 Pink Floyd - Echoes: The Best of Pink Floyd - 1343%
2 The Who - Then and Now - 863%
3 Annie Lennox - Eurythmics Greatest Hits - 500%
4 Dido - Life For Rent - 412%
5 Razorlight - Up All Night - 335%
6 Robbie Williams - Greatest Hits - 320%
7 Joss Stone - Mind, Body and Soul - 309%
8 Sting - The Very Best of Sting & The Police - 300%
9 Travis - Singles - 268%
10 Madonna - Immaculate Collection - 200%

As Sconzey pointed out in a comment, the real winners here are the record companies.

Laconian Scottie argues that by exposing this hypocrisy, the organisers might unintentionally have had a positive effect.
Were you one of the many people who watched an event designed to help the poorest people in the world and reacted by buying a CD?

Update: Independent, 'A concert? Why is this one special?' How Africa was unmoved by Live8

Sunday, July 03, 2005

Terms and Conditions Apply

So we've had that there Live 8. There have been a lot of criticisms of the event. Just in the some of the blogs I read, Justin has had a pop, as have Nosemonkey and Nick. Even I've had a (half-hearted) go.
There are three main issues.
  1. It's been badly planned (although the show seems to have gone ok from what I've seen).
  2. It's never edifying watching multi-millionares talking about making poverty history (especially when they're likely to sell more CDs and make even more money in the process).
  3. It's going to attract a crowd who mostly don't give an underarm throw about global poverty.
In short, it's a pants idea. I did watch some of it and it seemed to be reasonable enough entertainment. (I liked The Who if anyone's interested). It's not going to do much to help fight poverty though.
Of the blogs I read regularly, only Jim Bliss writes in support of Live 8. Go read, if you haven't already. Here's a sample:
Now, I don't know how many 16-year-old poverty activists Geldof has created in the past two weeks and will create tomorrow. Kids who are impressionable enough to have their minds changed by their pop star heroes. Certainly it'll be less than 1% of those who get fired up briefly by the event. But it'll be more than I'll manage to inspire in a lifetime of writing silly little articles.
It's a persuasive argument. Perhaps Live 8, for all its faults, will still have a positive effect. The BBC says "A TV audience of several hundred million were watching the gigs..."
That's a lot of people. How many will have been inspired to learn more about the causes of poverty? Probably a tiny percentage, but that's still going to be a lot of people.

There was one further critisism I would level at Live 8 though. I didn't see much information about poverty or its causes. Well, in the off chance that you, the reader, are one of those who'd like to know more about the issues, here are some links which might help start you off. I've not long started down this road myself, so don't expect great insight or detail.

It does seem that the this week's G8 will make some progress in tackling poverty. Unfortunately, there are some issues which will get little attention.

There is likely to be very little movement towards introducing fairer rules of international trade. Make Poverty History have a summary of what's needed. Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi told the BBC it was unlikely they [the G8] would agree to grant Africa "a fairer trading environment". Andrew Marr said the same when interviewed by Jonothan Ross during Live 8. After the G8 summit, the rules are still going to be overwhelmingly in favour of the wealthy nations. There is no economic or moral justification for this state of affairs. Vested interests are the major barrier to movement on this.

There is another area of great importance to development in Africa and elsewhere. It's conditionality, the attaching of conditions to debt relief and aid. At first glance it sounds like a sensible idea. The problem is that the conditions applied are based on something called the Washington Concensus. The conditions can be as damaging as the problems they are apparently designed to solve. Read George Monbiot for a flavour of the problem.

Tom Paine has more, explaining how the Washington Consensus has been attached to the recently announced debt relief programme:
According to G8 ministers, a country practicing "good governance" is one that wholeheartedly embraces the Washington Consensus. The 18 chosen countries are those that have reached "completion point" under HIPC [Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative], meaning that they have already complied with the onerous economic mandates. Since the G8 deal keeps this "conditionality" in place, new countries wishing to be included in future cancellation must still endure neoliberal "adjustments."
Ben Turok explains why this is problematic for African countries trying to develop:
One problem facing parliamentarians in Africa is that the IMF and World Bank [both dominated by the G8 and the US in particular] exercise major influence on government policies and programmes without these being referred to the scrutiny of parliaments. Another is that although these institutions claim that their recommendations are based on the recipient countries' strategic priorities, the imposed conditions override country preferences.
Conditionality removes power from local decision makers and places it in the hands of the G8. Given the problems with corruption in Africa, it is tempting to think that this is always a good idea. Unfortunately, in practise it means that decisions are taken by those who have a responsiblity only to rich nations. In the final analysis, the welfare of impoverished Africans will never have the same significance for these decision makers as the welfare of their own countries economic prosperity.

There are many examples of the Washington Consensus causing problems in developing countries. Argentina's economic collapse in 2001 is a recent example. There are lots more. Joseph Stiglitz has written an excellent book on the subject. It was reading this book which really opened my eyes to the problems in the international economic system. It's worth a read if you want to find out more about how the global economy works.

Yes, the G8 will make some significant progress in tackling African poverty, but it will only be a small step on a long road.

Saturday, July 02, 2005

Insomnia, Part 93

Ah! I've got to go to a wedding tomorrow (well today really). There's no chance I'll be sleeping more than 2 or 3 hours. Bah, bah, and bah again!

And what am I doing to occupy my time at this unspeakable hour?
I'm writing these two posts for my MP blog.
Sad, isn't it.

The wedding'll still be fun though.

Friday, July 01, 2005

Hamster Posting

Solidarity comrade!

What kind of person sends a hamster in the mail?
An idiot, I say.
Everyone knows we prefer to travel in style.
The Racing Hamster

Vroom! Vroom!

Genuine Excuse, No 1

Bloggage is going to be light over the next two or three days. I'm going to a wedding this weekend. As previously mentioned, it means I won't be able to attend the Make Poverty History march. I offer my support to everyone who makes it to the demonstration. (That's except for the extraordinarily tiny minority of likely trouble makers. Direct action is only useful if it's going to achieve something positive. You guys are having the opposite effect, actually helping the media propogate the "terrorist/extremist = peaceful protestor" meme. That's just not helpful to anyone.) Anyway, I'm sure it will be an excellent peaceful protest.

If your are worried about safety, be reassurred by this splendid P&J headline: Aberdeen hospital on standby to treat the sick and wounded
It's going to be carnage I tell you!
If you read the article you'll see that ARI hasn't actually done anything. In fact, they're expecting "business as usual".
"Specifically in Grampian we are not planning to cancel hospital admissions, or to employ additional staff.".
Carnage, I'm not joking!

In other news, I'd like to bring your attention to this story. Yes, Aberdeen City Council is proposing to move out of this building and move across the road into this one instead. The second is a spectacular building called Marischal College (second largest granite building in the world* and built by the family who lived here**). I had the photos on Flickr due to a conversation with Simon Holledge about buildings we'd like demolished. I nominated the very ugly St Nicholas House. And look at this:
"it would also result in the demolition of the council's much-derided base at St Nicholas House."
Outstanding, see the power of the blog! Right, where next?

*A trivial but marginally interesting fact***.
**And another.
***OK, maybe not interesting exactly...

We're Actually Not IDiots

The Home Office have released an estimate of the number of illegal imigrants in the country. Which is odd since Blair repeatedly claimed it wasn't possible to give a meaningful estimate during the election campaign.

Nosemonkey is rather angry about it. Too f**ing right!

Hello Mr Blair, are you listening? The public are actually not idiots. It might seem astonishing to you in your Westminster bubble, but most of us are able to remember what you said two months ago. (Sometimes we can even remember things from eight years ago.) Give it a rest, eh?