EU finances are not something I can claim to know a great deal about. As usual, it's not going to stop me from expressing an opinion on the subject.
Here's the story.
The first thing is that I can't see any justification for the British rebate. Twenty four nations follow one set of rules but Mrs Thatcher didn't like those rules so we've a special set just for us. We're like the spoilt kid in the class who sulks until they get what they want. The EU would be even more of a mess if every country negotiated the way the UK does. The rules are badly in need of reform and serious negotiations are required from all member states.
But for this man to be leading the calls for the rebate to be scrapped? No, I don't think so. Is he willing to discuss the removal of EU agricultural trade subsidies? Not likely.
This is the one area which could actually make a huge difference in the G8's stated goal of addressing poverty in Africa. I'm not saying that France is the only sticking point but I think it's fair to say that it is the biggest one. The French are apparently not even prepared to discuss reform of the CAP. Well, I'm afraid I find that hypocritical in the extreme (even Blair would struggle to achieve such a level).
So, let's get rid of the ludicrously unfair EU agricultural subsidies, let's put pressure on the US to do the same with their own protectionist agriculture policies, and let's scrap the British rebate. But let's not take advice from a posturing French President who won't even discuss reform of the EU's most indefensible policies.
Update: what some other people say.
The Sharpener (Nosemonkey) : Britain's rebate - A European view
Perfect (Robin) : The common agricultural policy: A ray of hope
And, writing from a country with similar issues to contend with, Hugo Kent : The Rebate Debate
Friday, June 10, 2005
Genuine People Personalities
Well I never!
"At first glance it may look like nothing has changed at all but the bins and benches all have unique personalities. They are what's called "generative" so that over time they develop more and more personality."Here I am, brain the size of a planet, and all they want me to do is let people sit on me...
Thursday, June 09, 2005
Inadvisable Posting
I'm going to make a prediction but first I need to set the scene. I've been awake for almost 24 hours. I'm trying to readjust my hours of conciousness so that they fit with those of most other people in the UK. At best, I'd say I'm in a dwam. I may have left a couple of ill considered comments as I've travelled the interwebs this afternoon. Ah well, not to worry, I'm still going to make this ill advised, bad taste, and probably quite offensive prediction.
I've been trying to avoid the coverage of the Michael Jackson trial. It's all a bit "media circus" for my liking. Unfortunately, it's pretty much unavoidable, even on BBC news, so I'm aware that the jury is considering it's verdict. It seems to me that the verdict, whatever it is, will in no way prove anything one way or the other. I'm not going to predict the verdict, I'm going more long term. I predict that if Michael Jackson is found guilty, and if he is sent to prison, it will be the first tentative steps in the foundation of a new religion.
OK, I warned you it was inadvisable. Still, if the two conditions are met, I'd say the religion of Jacksonism will be thriving within 20 years or so. Remember to check back in 20 years to congratulate me if I'm right.
I'm switching off my pc now and going to sleep.
I've been trying to avoid the coverage of the Michael Jackson trial. It's all a bit "media circus" for my liking. Unfortunately, it's pretty much unavoidable, even on BBC news, so I'm aware that the jury is considering it's verdict. It seems to me that the verdict, whatever it is, will in no way prove anything one way or the other. I'm not going to predict the verdict, I'm going more long term. I predict that if Michael Jackson is found guilty, and if he is sent to prison, it will be the first tentative steps in the foundation of a new religion.
OK, I warned you it was inadvisable. Still, if the two conditions are met, I'd say the religion of Jacksonism will be thriving within 20 years or so. Remember to check back in 20 years to congratulate me if I'm right.
I'm switching off my pc now and going to sleep.
Stay in your homes!
This is really just a footnote to this earlier post. In particular it's about this quotation from the front page of the P&J:
Trivialities
Number 1: It's actually David Capitanchik. The P&J have misspelt his name.
Number 2: Mr Capitanchick is not employed by the University of Aberdeen. He has not been employed there since 1993 (which explains why I didn't recognise his name). He was most recently employed by Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen but he retired in December 2004.
As I said, trivialities, but I thought they were worth correcting. The RGU profile does say "David is now a frequent commentator on current developments in his areas of expertise in both the national and international press." They aren't kidding. Here are some of Mr Capitanchik's comments.
The Times, 31/10/02
“I cannot think of a country where you are guaranteed to be safe...We are vulnerable right here in Britain. It would not take much for a suicide bomber to walk into Selfridges...”
[David points out that we are always vulnerable.]
The Scotsman, 14/04/03
"I wouldn’t be surprised if it was true a number of senior Iraqis had escaped in a convoy of Russian diplomats. Since Saddam came to power the Russians have been very close to his regime. It must be remembered that Saddam owes Russia $12 billion for arms deliveries and economic aid and the two are closely tied through this."
[David comments on the possible location of Saddam and other senior Iraqis]
The Evening Express, 16/12/03 (via google cache)
"Instead of the bloodshed of the Balkans I expect the new Iraq to be more like a devolved Britain."
[David predicts how events will unfold in Iraq. One of the few occassions I can find when David provides an optimistic prediction.]
The Scotsman, 17/09/04
"If it had been terrorists the consequences could have been horrendous. Suicide bombers would have blown themselves up or attacked someone with knives."
[David comments after journalists gain unauthorised access to the Scottish Parliament.]
The Sunday Times, 26/09/04
"It’s no excuse to say that security would have been tighter when the royal family are in residence. The palace is susceptible to a Brighton bombing-style attack, in which a terrorist was able to build a bomb into a wall (in advance)."
[David commenting on a reporter gaining access to Holyroodhouse.]
The Scotsman, 01/04/05
"I was surprised when Gordon Brown encouraged people to join the anti-poverty march which I think is an occasion to worry about."
[David warns against joining the G8 march. A particular favourite of mine, this one.]
Daily Record, 31/05/05
"Given the current terror threat, it would be unreasonable for Britain - the Americans' main coalition partner - to refuse their request."
[David agrees with Blair's decision to allow 2000 heavily armed US Marines to help guard Bush during the G8 summit.]
There are more but I think you get the idea. Doomed, doomed, I tell ye! OK, I suspect the worst that can be definiteively said about Mr Capitanchik is that he's a media rent-a-quote but I wouldn't even be as unkind as to say that. Also, I don't have to. Alan Taylor, writing in The Sunday Herald, comments on the Tartan Bollocks Awards , 2004, "when due recognition is given to stories whose relationship with reality is tenuous to say the least."
But terrorism expert David Capitanchick has warned north-east oil firms could be attacked by anti-capitalist activists. The Aberdeen University academic said multinational oil companies were prime targets for anti-globalisation demonstrations.I like to google for information about experts when I see them quoted in the local media. In this case I'm also interested because I actually studied terrorism at Aberdeen University in 1996. There are no shocking revelations to be found here but I thought I'd share what I did find. Anyone who's interested can click the permalink for more.
Trivialities
Number 1: It's actually David Capitanchik. The P&J have misspelt his name.
Number 2: Mr Capitanchick is not employed by the University of Aberdeen. He has not been employed there since 1993 (which explains why I didn't recognise his name). He was most recently employed by Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen but he retired in December 2004.
As I said, trivialities, but I thought they were worth correcting. The RGU profile does say "David is now a frequent commentator on current developments in his areas of expertise in both the national and international press." They aren't kidding. Here are some of Mr Capitanchik's comments.
The Times, 31/10/02
“I cannot think of a country where you are guaranteed to be safe...We are vulnerable right here in Britain. It would not take much for a suicide bomber to walk into Selfridges...”
[David points out that we are always vulnerable.]
The Scotsman, 14/04/03
"I wouldn’t be surprised if it was true a number of senior Iraqis had escaped in a convoy of Russian diplomats. Since Saddam came to power the Russians have been very close to his regime. It must be remembered that Saddam owes Russia $12 billion for arms deliveries and economic aid and the two are closely tied through this."
[David comments on the possible location of Saddam and other senior Iraqis]
The Evening Express, 16/12/03 (via google cache)
"Instead of the bloodshed of the Balkans I expect the new Iraq to be more like a devolved Britain."
[David predicts how events will unfold in Iraq. One of the few occassions I can find when David provides an optimistic prediction.]
The Scotsman, 17/09/04
"If it had been terrorists the consequences could have been horrendous. Suicide bombers would have blown themselves up or attacked someone with knives."
[David comments after journalists gain unauthorised access to the Scottish Parliament.]
The Sunday Times, 26/09/04
"It’s no excuse to say that security would have been tighter when the royal family are in residence. The palace is susceptible to a Brighton bombing-style attack, in which a terrorist was able to build a bomb into a wall (in advance)."
[David commenting on a reporter gaining access to Holyroodhouse.]
The Scotsman, 01/04/05
"I was surprised when Gordon Brown encouraged people to join the anti-poverty march which I think is an occasion to worry about."
[David warns against joining the G8 march. A particular favourite of mine, this one.]
Daily Record, 31/05/05
"Given the current terror threat, it would be unreasonable for Britain - the Americans' main coalition partner - to refuse their request."
[David agrees with Blair's decision to allow 2000 heavily armed US Marines to help guard Bush during the G8 summit.]
There are more but I think you get the idea. Doomed, doomed, I tell ye! OK, I suspect the worst that can be definiteively said about Mr Capitanchik is that he's a media rent-a-quote but I wouldn't even be as unkind as to say that. Also, I don't have to. Alan Taylor, writing in The Sunday Herald, comments on the Tartan Bollocks Awards , 2004, "when due recognition is given to stories whose relationship with reality is tenuous to say the least."
In truth, there was never any doubt about whose bollocks would win the top award. Step forward Jason Allardyce of the teuchter edition of the Funday Times. In March, Mr Allardyce reported that “government experts” believed that the Holyrood parliament could be attacked by “a lone terrorist with a lightweight mortar” standing on Salisbury Crags...Stay in your homes!
Credence was lent to this incredible tale by... rent-an-academic, David Capitanchik, “a terrorism expert” at Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen, who said he expected surveillance of the hills overlooking the parliament site to be stepped up in view of the danger of a mortar attack.
Apparently, “terrorists were most likely to strike during visits by foreign dignitaries and eminent people.... The parliament is exposed,” added Mr Capitanchick observantly, “and if things get really tough for terrorists in London, which they are, and if they see things are not so tight in Edinburgh, they could come here. Al-Qaeda does not know much about devolution. We are as vulnerable in Scotland as any other place in the UK.”
To be a Scotsman
What's going on here then? I hope the blancmanges were watching.
We really do live in interesting times.
There's a story from in the Press and Journal, Wed 8th, 2005, (sadly, the story isn't online) which gives a good illustration of why I worry about the possibility of Scottish independence.
The article is about a Burger King poster used in Hungary which translates as "Burger King is where a Scot takes you for a meal becasue it's so cheap". OK, Burger King is one of those companies I boycott for various reasons, and the slogan doesn't seem particularly funny to me, but it doesn't really bother me much.
The same cannot be said for SNP MSP Bruce Crawford:
I'd say this little episode probably tells us two things.
a) Mr Crawford is taking this advert a bit too seriously. 1
b) MSPs don't really have enough useful things to be getting on with.
Relax guy, it's just a joke. As is this:
Q) Do you know how copper wire was invented?
A) Two Scotsmen were arguing over a penny.
Oh, I've demeaned my country. Outrageous! 2
1: There are lots of valid reasons why MSPs might want to complain about Burger King marketing stragegies. The above just isn't one of them.
2: Please don't misunderstand, I am proud of my country. I am particularly proud of our ability to laugh at ourselves. If only all nations would take the time to do this more often, I feel the world would be a better place. 3
3: This was supposed to be a post with no serious points in it at all. The footnotes put paid to that idea.
We really do live in interesting times.
There's a story from in the Press and Journal, Wed 8th, 2005, (sadly, the story isn't online) which gives a good illustration of why I worry about the possibility of Scottish independence.
The article is about a Burger King poster used in Hungary which translates as "Burger King is where a Scot takes you for a meal becasue it's so cheap". OK, Burger King is one of those companies I boycott for various reasons, and the slogan doesn't seem particularly funny to me, but it doesn't really bother me much.
The same cannot be said for SNP MSP Bruce Crawford:
"This advert is by no means idiosyncratic [as described by a BK spokesperson]. It demeans the people of Scotland. I hope Burger King in Hungary do not produce any more of their so called idiosyncratic posters demeaning Scotland... This advert is clearly an unfair representation of the Scottish people and needs updating".He also descibed the advert as a "slap in the face" to the people of Scotland.
I'd say this little episode probably tells us two things.
a) Mr Crawford is taking this advert a bit too seriously. 1
b) MSPs don't really have enough useful things to be getting on with.
Relax guy, it's just a joke. As is this:
Q) Do you know how copper wire was invented?
A) Two Scotsmen were arguing over a penny.
Oh, I've demeaned my country. Outrageous! 2
1: There are lots of valid reasons why MSPs might want to complain about Burger King marketing stragegies. The above just isn't one of them.
2: Please don't misunderstand, I am proud of my country. I am particularly proud of our ability to laugh at ourselves. If only all nations would take the time to do this more often, I feel the world would be a better place. 3
3: This was supposed to be a post with no serious points in it at all. The footnotes put paid to that idea.
Wednesday, June 08, 2005
Quick, before they all go to bed
I've just put up a new post at my blog about myMP, Anne Begg. Anne's official site doesn't look like it's going to be launched for a while yet so I'm going to continue to provide this voluntary service in the meantime.
In other news (ie me, me, me!), I'm having some difficulty in maintaining conciousness at the same time as the rest of the country. Insomnia don't you know. My posts might be slightly out of sync with those of "normal people" for a wee while. In honour of this, I'm going to adopt a new motto:
The early bird may catch the worm but the early worm gets eaten.
One more thing. Recently I've not been managing to respond to as many comments as I'd like. [Insert suitable excuse here.] Sorry about that, normal service will resume shortly.
In other news (ie me, me, me!), I'm having some difficulty in maintaining conciousness at the same time as the rest of the country. Insomnia don't you know. My posts might be slightly out of sync with those of "normal people" for a wee while. In honour of this, I'm going to adopt a new motto:
The early bird may catch the worm but the early worm gets eaten.
One more thing. Recently I've not been managing to respond to as many comments as I'd like. [Insert suitable excuse here.] Sorry about that, normal service will resume shortly.
Anarchic Loon Invasion
The media is becoming increasing obsessed with the potential for public disorder during the G8 protests in July. I've just listened to a good 15 minutes worth of speculation on this very issue on Newsnight Scotland. The first point I should make is that I'm sure there will be a group of people who are intent on causing public disorder during the protests. They will be a tiny minority. The overwhelming majority of people will demonstrate peacefully and lawfully. The media have their own reasons for concentrating their attentions on the extremist fringe, and those reasons are often rather more complicated than a first glance would suggest. I'm going to avoid that particular hot potato for the moment and concentrate on another institution which has a vested interest in overstating the extremist involvement in the protests.
Yes, it's that bastion of honesty and integrity, Her Majesty's Government (forgive me if I'm preaching to the converted here). New Labour under our great leader do not want you to protest in Edinburgh or anywhere else. If a million people turn up only to be told that it's pretty much business as usual, it'll be embarrassing for the government. Blair knows Bush doesn't intend to give the kind of commitment needed to affect radical change. What's more, Blair himself doesn't intend to give that kind of commitment. The recent announcement of an increase in aid to 0.7% of GDP by 2015 is just another example of posture politics. It's a long standing commitment which should have been met years ago. No, the government don't want you there because they'd find it all a bit awkward and uncomfortable.
And so, they are more than happy to play up the extremist fringe elements. It's going to be anarchy out there. Your children will be in danger. Fighting, stone throwing, fires, overturned cars, riots beatings, bombs, tear gas...
Stay in your homes!
And many potential protestors probably will stay at home. This will suit the government right down to the ground. Groundswell, what groundswell?
Y'see, the only way the current situation is going to even begin to change is if a million people do march peacefully on Edinburgh and Gleneagles. This will be something extraordinary, something unique, and something very difficult to ignore. One million people protesting for radical change to the international economic system. The government doesn't want that. They're happy to posture and to tinker round the edges.
So stay in your homes!
Now that you've read the above you're either thinking
a) Tell me something I don't know.
b) I never thought of it like that.
c) Why am I reading this conspiracy nut job's rantings?
If it's c) you should know it's not about to get any better. I'm inclined to believe there's more too it than I've mentioned here, but I'll leave that for another post.
Here's a link to get flavour of it though.
Anyway, the point is that this type of thinking tends to provide a framework for me when I read certain news reports. Yesterdays P&J has a striking headline on it's front page:
Police Will Protect Oil Firms From G8 Attacks
But wait a minute, Mr McConnell was responding to fears from who exactly?
Perhaps it's these fears:
Stay in your homes!
Aberdeen is actually quite a long way from Gleneagles (the hotel is marked A) but I suppose it is convievable that a group of radical activists could make the trip north. Seems an indecently long way to travel when there's so much stuff to blow up in the central belt. Still, it is possible, an expert in terrorism said so.
Stay in your homes! No-one is safe from the anarchic loon invasion.
Yes, it's that bastion of honesty and integrity, Her Majesty's Government (forgive me if I'm preaching to the converted here). New Labour under our great leader do not want you to protest in Edinburgh or anywhere else. If a million people turn up only to be told that it's pretty much business as usual, it'll be embarrassing for the government. Blair knows Bush doesn't intend to give the kind of commitment needed to affect radical change. What's more, Blair himself doesn't intend to give that kind of commitment. The recent announcement of an increase in aid to 0.7% of GDP by 2015 is just another example of posture politics. It's a long standing commitment which should have been met years ago. No, the government don't want you there because they'd find it all a bit awkward and uncomfortable.
And so, they are more than happy to play up the extremist fringe elements. It's going to be anarchy out there. Your children will be in danger. Fighting, stone throwing, fires, overturned cars, riots beatings, bombs, tear gas...
Stay in your homes!
And many potential protestors probably will stay at home. This will suit the government right down to the ground. Groundswell, what groundswell?
Y'see, the only way the current situation is going to even begin to change is if a million people do march peacefully on Edinburgh and Gleneagles. This will be something extraordinary, something unique, and something very difficult to ignore. One million people protesting for radical change to the international economic system. The government doesn't want that. They're happy to posture and to tinker round the edges.
So stay in your homes!
Now that you've read the above you're either thinking
a) Tell me something I don't know.
b) I never thought of it like that.
c) Why am I reading this conspiracy nut job's rantings?
If it's c) you should know it's not about to get any better. I'm inclined to believe there's more too it than I've mentioned here, but I'll leave that for another post.
Here's a link to get flavour of it though.
Anyway, the point is that this type of thinking tends to provide a framework for me when I read certain news reports. Yesterdays P&J has a striking headline on it's front page:
Police Will Protect Oil Firms From G8 Attacks
The first minister has told north-east oil firms they will be protected from G8 protesters. During a visit to Aberdeen yesterday, Jack McConnell responded to fears that militant campaigners could target major oil companies as part of anti-capitalism protests timed to coincide with the world leaders' summit being held at Gleneagles in Perthshire next month.Holy crap, that sounds scary. Stay in your homes!
But wait a minute, Mr McConnell was responding to fears from who exactly?
Perhaps it's these fears:
But terrorism expert David Capitanchick has warned north-east oil firms could be attacked by anti-capitalist activists. The Aberdeen University academic said multinational oil companies were prime targets for anti-globalisation demonstrations.You see, it's so serious we need to consult an expert in terrorism. Terrorists, activists, protestors, demonstrators, they're all the same, every one intent on coming to blow us to smithereens.
Stay in your homes!
Aberdeen is actually quite a long way from Gleneagles (the hotel is marked A) but I suppose it is convievable that a group of radical activists could make the trip north. Seems an indecently long way to travel when there's so much stuff to blow up in the central belt. Still, it is possible, an expert in terrorism said so.
Stay in your homes! No-one is safe from the anarchic loon invasion.
Tuesday, June 07, 2005
Whatever!
I've already mentioned this story but I just have to bring it up again.
The BBC report:
From the Guardian (PA Report):
Update: From The Scotsman
(I have to say it's a sad day when I'm holding up Denis Thatcher as a paragon of virtue. It does say a great deal about our current "First Lady".)
The BBC report:
Mrs Blair gave an inside account of life in Downing Street in her speech, for which she was billed as the UK's "first lady". All tickets for the lecture - billed as the inside account of the "First Lady of Downing Street" - at the 2,500-seater Kennedy Centre were believed to have sold at between £33 ($60) and £52 ($95) each.It would be against the ministerial code for Mr Blair to receive money for such an engagement. The ministerial code does not impose these same conditions of behaviour on the spouse of the Prime Minister. One might speculate that the authors of the code did not feel it was necessary to explicitly state such a condition. After all, one can expect a certain amount of integrity without having to formalise it in the ministerial code.
From the Guardian (PA Report):
The Conservatives have accused her of exploiting her husband's job and urged her to hand her fee - thought to be £30,000 - to charity.I don't know what standard fee a QC might expect for a public speaking engagement, but I'm reasonably certain it isn't £30,000. What irritates me the most about this story is that the Prime Minister and his wife don't even seem to understand why people might be unhappy about it.
Questioned on the row during his visit to Washington the Prime Minister gave an exasperated shrug and told reporters: "I don't think there's ever anything I can say on these things that can make it better."Yeah, like, whatever!
Update: From The Scotsman
In the lecture, Mrs Blair complained that she was the victim of sexism about her money-making activities, comparing her situation to that of Baroness Thatcher's husband.Yeah but, no but, yeah but, no but, what happened was, right...
"Denis Thatcher also had a number of outside interests. No-one found anything wrong with that," Mrs Blair said.
But although Sir Denis served as a director of several companies while Lady Thatcher was prime minister, there are no recorded instances of him publicly speaking about his life as her husband, much less being paid to do so.
(I have to say it's a sad day when I'm holding up Denis Thatcher as a paragon of virtue. It does say a great deal about our current "First Lady".)
Feed the Egos
I've put one of those poll thingys in my sidebar. Your opinions are always welcome. Remember, it's just a bit of fun.
Edit: I've just cast the first vote. It might not last long.
Update: It didn't. It's gone. Pop-up ads, I can't be doing with them.
This post has become entirely redundant. I'm going to leave it here as a testament to an experiment which lasted less than an hour.
Edit: I've just cast the first vote. It might not last long.
Update: It didn't. It's gone. Pop-up ads, I can't be doing with them.
This post has become entirely redundant. I'm going to leave it here as a testament to an experiment which lasted less than an hour.
Half Baked Philosophy Pie
The First Slice
This might be the start of an irregular series of introspective posts. On the other hand it may be part 1 in a series of 1. We’ll see how this one goes for a start. I’m not well read when it comes to philosophical issues so I’d advise anyone reading to prepare for extreme naivety. I’ve been thinking over my political compass test results among other things. In the test I came out as somewhere between Nelson Mandela and the Dalai Lama and although I’d like to claim that these comparisons are justified, I have to admit that they are not. This post is an attempt to examine why this is the case.
As a starting point, I’ve been considering the conflict between my intellectually reasoned opinions and my normal modes of behaviour. In some wonderful utopian future there would be no conflict and humanity would be at peace with itself. Today, in June 2005, conflict certainly exists. I often criticise politicians for their inability to live up to their own rhetoric, but how often do I apply the same conditions to my own behaviour? Perhaps the answer is not often enough.
Bearing in mind my intellectual position as a libertarian leftie (of which more later) it might be useful if I try to explain a little about myself and how I interact with other people. I don’t do it well. Well, that’s not strictly true, I can do it well, but I don’t do it well very often. It generally depends on my frame of mind. My problem is that I tend to find interacting with individual people irritating, intimidating, and confusing. I seem to be impatient by default and naturally suspicious of the intentions of others. I can be judgemental, quickly categorising people in order to provide a framework for the interaction. I often become intensely irritated with my own behaviour in social situations and this then exacerbates my impatience and discomfort. I find that people can be just so difficult to predict, so inconsiderate, so irrational even. In essence, I can lose a perfectly happy and optimistic state of mind just by going to the corner shop to buy a litre of milk. Five minutes in a queue at the till and I’ve decided the entire world is doomed (and probably not worth saving) due to the inherent stupidity and selfishness of the human race. I should add that I do include myself in all these criticisms. As a result of the above I spend a great deal of time alone. I’m not good at keeping in touch with my friends, not because I don’t like my friends, but because I don’t find it easy to talk to people.
I could try to explain why I think my default positions are this way but it’d be lengthy and speculative and probably not very interesting. The point is that this is the way I behave when I’m not consciously thinking about the way I behave. Wherever you stand on the nurture versus nature debate, I believe most people would accept that by the time we reach adulthood we have developed a set of predispositions in our behaviours. (The nurture versus nature debate itself can keep for another time.)
I should imagine that the difference between my behaviour and my political opinions is fairly apparent. In abstract, I think the world would be a better place if we all took the time to be a bit nicer to each other, but if you were to walk past me in the street I wouldn’t even look in your direction. In abstract, I believe that many of the problems in 21st Century society are caused by the disconnections which exist in society, but I’m one of the most disconnected people you’re ever likely to meet. In abstract, I believe that the rehabilitation of criminals is better for society than punishment, but if I caught you trying to break into my house I’d not be overly concerned with your circumstances or rehabilitation programme. There are many more examples but I’m sure you get the point.
There are those who might say that this highlights a problem with my intellectual position. Perhaps my position is pie in the sky woolly headed thinking based on an unrealistic view of humanity. In some respects I can see that this argument has a lot of weight. The libertarian left view of the world requires empathy and cooperation at a local, national, and international level. Maybe this is just asking too much of people. Perhaps the truth is that selfishness and intolerance have to be accepted and adopted into our world view.
It’s a strong argument, especially given my own day to day reactions. So, should I rethink my intellectual position to accommodate these realities or should I attempt to overcome my predispositions in order to accommodate my intellectual position? It is here that I feel we have reached the root of this little investigation. Are we, as human adults, pre-programmed robots following a proscribed set of behaviours, unable to consciously alter our actions? It isn’t an easy question and I won’t even begin to attempt to pretend to know the answer. On the one hand, the fact that I’m writing this makes me a conscious being, but on the other, my everyday reactions to events appear to be beyond conscious control.
My feeling is that we should not accept that our behaviour is predetermined. For me, this would be an acceptance of defeat, an acceptance that humanity cannot change for the better. Whether it is true is almost irrelevant, the important thing is that we continue to try. It may be true that my intellectual positions are based on idealism but that shouldn’t stop me from trying to live according to them. The conflict might continue until the day I take my last breath, but if I’ve won just one battle over my predisposed behaviours, then at least I’ll die knowing it was possible. And perhaps, just perhaps, the world will be the tiniest fraction better than it was before the conflict started.
This might be the start of an irregular series of introspective posts. On the other hand it may be part 1 in a series of 1. We’ll see how this one goes for a start. I’m not well read when it comes to philosophical issues so I’d advise anyone reading to prepare for extreme naivety. I’ve been thinking over my political compass test results among other things. In the test I came out as somewhere between Nelson Mandela and the Dalai Lama and although I’d like to claim that these comparisons are justified, I have to admit that they are not. This post is an attempt to examine why this is the case.
As a starting point, I’ve been considering the conflict between my intellectually reasoned opinions and my normal modes of behaviour. In some wonderful utopian future there would be no conflict and humanity would be at peace with itself. Today, in June 2005, conflict certainly exists. I often criticise politicians for their inability to live up to their own rhetoric, but how often do I apply the same conditions to my own behaviour? Perhaps the answer is not often enough.
Bearing in mind my intellectual position as a libertarian leftie (of which more later) it might be useful if I try to explain a little about myself and how I interact with other people. I don’t do it well. Well, that’s not strictly true, I can do it well, but I don’t do it well very often. It generally depends on my frame of mind. My problem is that I tend to find interacting with individual people irritating, intimidating, and confusing. I seem to be impatient by default and naturally suspicious of the intentions of others. I can be judgemental, quickly categorising people in order to provide a framework for the interaction. I often become intensely irritated with my own behaviour in social situations and this then exacerbates my impatience and discomfort. I find that people can be just so difficult to predict, so inconsiderate, so irrational even. In essence, I can lose a perfectly happy and optimistic state of mind just by going to the corner shop to buy a litre of milk. Five minutes in a queue at the till and I’ve decided the entire world is doomed (and probably not worth saving) due to the inherent stupidity and selfishness of the human race. I should add that I do include myself in all these criticisms. As a result of the above I spend a great deal of time alone. I’m not good at keeping in touch with my friends, not because I don’t like my friends, but because I don’t find it easy to talk to people.
I could try to explain why I think my default positions are this way but it’d be lengthy and speculative and probably not very interesting. The point is that this is the way I behave when I’m not consciously thinking about the way I behave. Wherever you stand on the nurture versus nature debate, I believe most people would accept that by the time we reach adulthood we have developed a set of predispositions in our behaviours. (The nurture versus nature debate itself can keep for another time.)
I should imagine that the difference between my behaviour and my political opinions is fairly apparent. In abstract, I think the world would be a better place if we all took the time to be a bit nicer to each other, but if you were to walk past me in the street I wouldn’t even look in your direction. In abstract, I believe that many of the problems in 21st Century society are caused by the disconnections which exist in society, but I’m one of the most disconnected people you’re ever likely to meet. In abstract, I believe that the rehabilitation of criminals is better for society than punishment, but if I caught you trying to break into my house I’d not be overly concerned with your circumstances or rehabilitation programme. There are many more examples but I’m sure you get the point.
There are those who might say that this highlights a problem with my intellectual position. Perhaps my position is pie in the sky woolly headed thinking based on an unrealistic view of humanity. In some respects I can see that this argument has a lot of weight. The libertarian left view of the world requires empathy and cooperation at a local, national, and international level. Maybe this is just asking too much of people. Perhaps the truth is that selfishness and intolerance have to be accepted and adopted into our world view.
It’s a strong argument, especially given my own day to day reactions. So, should I rethink my intellectual position to accommodate these realities or should I attempt to overcome my predispositions in order to accommodate my intellectual position? It is here that I feel we have reached the root of this little investigation. Are we, as human adults, pre-programmed robots following a proscribed set of behaviours, unable to consciously alter our actions? It isn’t an easy question and I won’t even begin to attempt to pretend to know the answer. On the one hand, the fact that I’m writing this makes me a conscious being, but on the other, my everyday reactions to events appear to be beyond conscious control.
My feeling is that we should not accept that our behaviour is predetermined. For me, this would be an acceptance of defeat, an acceptance that humanity cannot change for the better. Whether it is true is almost irrelevant, the important thing is that we continue to try. It may be true that my intellectual positions are based on idealism but that shouldn’t stop me from trying to live according to them. The conflict might continue until the day I take my last breath, but if I’ve won just one battle over my predisposed behaviours, then at least I’ll die knowing it was possible. And perhaps, just perhaps, the world will be the tiniest fraction better than it was before the conflict started.
Monday, June 06, 2005
Not Much Continues to Happen
I've just put a new post up at my blog about Anne Begg. It looks like my previous prediction on Anne's official interweb activities were overly optimistic.
In news about me, there isn't much of it. I've fallen a bit behind keeping up to date with the blogs I normally read. I'm hoping to spend this evening catching up.
In news about me, there isn't much of it. I've fallen a bit behind keeping up to date with the blogs I normally read. I'm hoping to spend this evening catching up.
Sunday, June 05, 2005
Celebrity Hissy Fit
The bigger the star the less considerate they are towards their fans. It seems to have become written in stone as one of the celebrity 10 commandments. Diva's, of both sexes, continually let down their fans at the drop of a hat. It's just one small facet of the vapid celebrity obsessed cultural scenery of the early 21st Century. I find it all rather distasteful.
There are a small number of respected public figures who are able to rise above such self-obsessed posturing. Tragically, one such figure has recently succumbed to the pressures of fame and let himself slide down the slippery slope which comes from believing one's own media hype. This is particulary shocking given the high regard with which I had previously held this once great public figure.
You can read the story of another sad decline into the shallow world of the celebrity here.
It's not hard to imagine the scene as it unfolded in the luxury custom built engine shed trailer:
Manager - "Come on T, they're all waiting for you out there."
T - "I don't care. These people make me sick!"
Manager - "But they've paid a lot of money to see you. You can't let them all down."
T - "I don't give a flying monkeys how much money the great unwashed have paid. I will not do anything until you've brought me 500 blue M&M's and a British Rail tuna and cucumber sandwich!"
Manager - "Now T, you know that BR was sold off years ago.."
T - "GET OUT! How dare you speak to me like that!"
It's enough to bring a tear to the eye. Where have all the role models gone?
There are a small number of respected public figures who are able to rise above such self-obsessed posturing. Tragically, one such figure has recently succumbed to the pressures of fame and let himself slide down the slippery slope which comes from believing one's own media hype. This is particulary shocking given the high regard with which I had previously held this once great public figure.
You can read the story of another sad decline into the shallow world of the celebrity here.
It's not hard to imagine the scene as it unfolded in the luxury custom built engine shed trailer:
Manager - "Come on T, they're all waiting for you out there."
T - "I don't care. These people make me sick!"
Manager - "But they've paid a lot of money to see you. You can't let them all down."
T - "I don't give a flying monkeys how much money the great unwashed have paid. I will not do anything until you've brought me 500 blue M&M's and a British Rail tuna and cucumber sandwich!"
Manager - "Now T, you know that BR was sold off years ago.."
T - "GET OUT! How dare you speak to me like that!"
It's enough to bring a tear to the eye. Where have all the role models gone?
Saturday, June 04, 2005
What Would Jules Say?
I've decided to try to avoid politics in my weekend posts as a general rule of thumb. Here's a science story from the Guardian:
Journey to the centre of the Earth
Japanese researchers are going to "bore through 7,000 metres of crust below the seabed while floating in 2,500 metres of water - requiring a drill pipe 25 times the height of the Empire State building."
Is that cool or what? They're going to try to break through the Earth's crust and take samples of the mantle. Far out dude!
I'm not a scientist but I think I can add a little to the research:
I'm joking. I'm sure they know what they're doing.
Update: Another interesting *ahem* science story. It's World Jump Day. Holy leaping environmentalists, Batpeople! Are you up (and then down) for it?
Link via the Gurn.
Journey to the centre of the Earth
Japanese researchers are going to "bore through 7,000 metres of crust below the seabed while floating in 2,500 metres of water - requiring a drill pipe 25 times the height of the Empire State building."
Is that cool or what? They're going to try to break through the Earth's crust and take samples of the mantle. Far out dude!
I'm not a scientist but I think I can add a little to the research:
The team wants to retrieve samples from the mantle, six miles down, to learn more about what triggers undersea earthquakes...Here's my prediction. Scientists will discover that drilling a sodding great hole in the crust will be one of the triggers for undersea earthquakes.
I'm joking. I'm sure they know what they're doing.
Update: Another interesting *ahem* science story. It's World Jump Day. Holy leaping environmentalists, Batpeople! Are you up (and then down) for it?
Link via the Gurn.
Late Night Navel Gazing
I'm not actually sure if the phrase "navel gazing" is in widespread use or not. I've ripped off taken my inspiration from Nick Barlow who uses it as a post category. Here's some of it.
I've just received delivery of my new pet. He came all the way from the Arizona desert. Thank you.
I've also taken the test at the political compass today. I'm a left of centre libertarian (not a huge surprise). I fall somewhere between Nelson Mandela and the Dalia Lama, which is nice. Thanks to Stuart for pointing me at it. I'd seen it before but had never actually got round to doing the test.
Today was also the day when this picture became the most viewed in my Flickr photostream. I'd like to think this is due to the brilliance of my satire. Alas, I have the feeling other forces may be at work. Almost no-one clicks the link to the blog post it relates to, and without an explanation I dread to think what people make of it. Ah well.
In other blog news, the May award for the creepiest keyword search visitor goes to:
"2005 email contact director small arms ammunition company"
Yikes! I'm glad it was a short visit.
Finally, a quick mention of my proxy blog for Anne Begg. To be honest, nothing much is happening. It's been 4 weeks since Anne was re-elected and still no official word on the interwebs. The latest available news still comes from Anne's campaign blog. It's not quite as relevant as it could be. I'm reasonably sure Anne's new website and blog will be up at the beginning of next week. We shall see.
Update: I forgot to mention that I'm still not smoking. I've lost track of exactly how long it's been but it must be around 3 months or so. My doctor said this was probably why I had that sinus infection. I suggested I should start smoking again but he didn't seem overly enamoured by the idea.
I've just received delivery of my new pet. He came all the way from the Arizona desert. Thank you.
I've also taken the test at the political compass today. I'm a left of centre libertarian (not a huge surprise). I fall somewhere between Nelson Mandela and the Dalia Lama, which is nice. Thanks to Stuart for pointing me at it. I'd seen it before but had never actually got round to doing the test.
Today was also the day when this picture became the most viewed in my Flickr photostream. I'd like to think this is due to the brilliance of my satire. Alas, I have the feeling other forces may be at work. Almost no-one clicks the link to the blog post it relates to, and without an explanation I dread to think what people make of it. Ah well.
In other blog news, the May award for the creepiest keyword search visitor goes to:
"2005 email contact director small arms ammunition company"
Yikes! I'm glad it was a short visit.
Finally, a quick mention of my proxy blog for Anne Begg. To be honest, nothing much is happening. It's been 4 weeks since Anne was re-elected and still no official word on the interwebs. The latest available news still comes from Anne's campaign blog. It's not quite as relevant as it could be. I'm reasonably sure Anne's new website and blog will be up at the beginning of next week. We shall see.
Update: I forgot to mention that I'm still not smoking. I've lost track of exactly how long it's been but it must be around 3 months or so. My doctor said this was probably why I had that sinus infection. I suggested I should start smoking again but he didn't seem overly enamoured by the idea.
Friday, June 03, 2005
Moving On
The Washington Post is reporting on an announcement by the Iraqi Interior Minister, Bayan Jabr: Iraq Puts Civilian Toll at 12,000
A quick reminder of the words of our great leader.
BAGHDAD, June 2 -- Violence in the course of the insurgency over the past 18 months has claimed the lives of 12,000 Iraqis, Interior Minister Bayan Jabr said Thursday, giving the first official count for the largest category of victims of bombings, ambushes and other increasingly deadly attacks.At first glance this seems a low figure given that the internationally respected Iraq Body Count organisation is reporting a much higher death toll. Reading the article, the difference is readily explainable. The 12,000 figure refers to the last 18 months only, and only includes deaths caused by the insurgency. The article goes on to comment on US policy with regard to civilian casualties. It casts more light on the disparity.
No official totals have been released for those dead, or for the total number of civilian casualties since the start of the war. The U.S. military says it does not keep a comprehensive tally of people it has killed in combat, although it has released numbers of dead in major operations and has acknowledged civilians it has killed if it has become generally known that those people died during a U.S. firefight or attack.There we have it. It seems that US military policy is to admit to killing civilians only when it has already become generally known. If it's only the US military themselves who know, well, they just aren't going to bother telling anyone else what they've done. You can see their point, why should they? It'll only cause bad publicity.
A quick reminder of the words of our great leader.
In addition I know that Iraq has been a deeply divisive issue in this country - that's been very, very clear. But I also know and believe that after this election people want to move on; they want to focus on the future in Iraq and here.That's right, move on, nothing to see here...
Tony Blair, 6th May, 2005
Thursday, June 02, 2005
Live8 - Has anyone actually thought this through?
I'm with Justin at Chicken Yoghurt for the most part. What's the point? I do have to say that I think Sir Bob probably has good intentions although I've really got nothing to back that up.
The whole Live8 event just seems like a masive distraction from the actual point of the G8 protests. It's looks like a last minute, ill conceived idea.
Justin has most of the bases covered (although I actually like Coldplay, and enough to admit to liking them too). Here's another reason why it isn't a good idea.
Sir Bob called for everyone to make their way up to Edinburgh after the Live8 concert in London on July 2nd. This has caused a lot of fuss and bother in the media. To be honest, I think the idea that safety and security will be an issue is sideshow. I'd like a million people there, Edinburgh is a big place. What I'd really like is for them all to be there at the Make Poverty History demonstration on the 2nd July. It's a demonstration for which plans are well advanced. In an earlier post I mentioned that I'd like to go but have an important wedding to attend that day. Sir Bob doesn't seem to have considered that it might have been better to have coordinated his plans with the organisers of this demonstartion. If anything, the Live8 concert in London will actually reduce attendance at the official MPH demonstration. That doesn't seem like very good idea to me.
Has anyone actually thought this through?
The whole Live8 event just seems like a masive distraction from the actual point of the G8 protests. It's looks like a last minute, ill conceived idea.
Justin has most of the bases covered (although I actually like Coldplay, and enough to admit to liking them too). Here's another reason why it isn't a good idea.
Sir Bob called for everyone to make their way up to Edinburgh after the Live8 concert in London on July 2nd. This has caused a lot of fuss and bother in the media. To be honest, I think the idea that safety and security will be an issue is sideshow. I'd like a million people there, Edinburgh is a big place. What I'd really like is for them all to be there at the Make Poverty History demonstration on the 2nd July. It's a demonstration for which plans are well advanced. In an earlier post I mentioned that I'd like to go but have an important wedding to attend that day. Sir Bob doesn't seem to have considered that it might have been better to have coordinated his plans with the organisers of this demonstartion. If anything, the Live8 concert in London will actually reduce attendance at the official MPH demonstration. That doesn't seem like very good idea to me.
Has anyone actually thought this through?
Comment Policy
Update - 06/04/06
I'm currently switching back to Blogger comments. Please use the Blogger comment system please. The Haloscan system is only going to be there till the older comments drop off.
Update off
Comment policy? I know. I write one marginally interesting post and it's all gone to my head. What am I like?
In fact, I actually felt the need to edit a comment for the first time the other day, so I thought this might save me the bother of having to do it again. Here we go:
Comments are welcome. I like comments. Feel free to express your opinions. I'm always interested to know what people think. Generally, I prefer not to have swearing in the comments unless the post also contains swearing (which happens only occassionally). I could explain why I prefer it this way, but it'd be dull. I just do. If you must, why not use the ar**ing star method?
Comments containing personal insults aimed at myself or other commenters will be deleted. I'm happy to discuss issues and argue different points of view, but I find mud-slinging tedious.
Your email address will never be posted on this blog and will never be passed on to a third party. I hate SPAM.
If you want to leave your homepage URL, especially if it's a blog, that's just fine and dandy. People can then read more of what you've got to say, if they're so inclined.
It should be a personal webpage URL of some kind though. The edited comment I mentioned above left a URL for an online Casino. I just deleted the link.
OK, that'll do. This page may be edited further if I feel the need.
I'm currently switching back to Blogger comments. Please use the Blogger comment system please. The Haloscan system is only going to be there till the older comments drop off.
Update off
Comment policy? I know. I write one marginally interesting post and it's all gone to my head. What am I like?
In fact, I actually felt the need to edit a comment for the first time the other day, so I thought this might save me the bother of having to do it again. Here we go:
Comments are welcome. I like comments. Feel free to express your opinions. I'm always interested to know what people think. Generally, I prefer not to have swearing in the comments unless the post also contains swearing (which happens only occassionally). I could explain why I prefer it this way, but it'd be dull. I just do. If you must, why not use the ar**ing star method?
Comments containing personal insults aimed at myself or other commenters will be deleted. I'm happy to discuss issues and argue different points of view, but I find mud-slinging tedious.
Your email address will never be posted on this blog and will never be passed on to a third party. I hate SPAM.
If you want to leave your homepage URL, especially if it's a blog, that's just fine and dandy. People can then read more of what you've got to say, if they're so inclined.
It should be a personal webpage URL of some kind though. The edited comment I mentioned above left a URL for an online Casino. I just deleted the link.
OK, that'll do. This page may be edited further if I feel the need.
Wednesday, June 01, 2005
If I could get a meme
It's a new meme from Blair.
This is how it works. I will answer five of the questions below. In return, I will tag three people who will highlight, copy and paste into their blogs who will answer five questions below and pass it on to three other bloggers.
If I could be a scientist... I'd invent cool stuff to save the planet (and grow a big beard).
If I could be a painter... I'd paint the living room. It really needs freshening up.
If I could be a doctor...
If I could be a farmer...
If I could be a gardener...
If I could be a missionary...
If I could be a lawyer...
If I could be an athlete...
If I could be an innkeeper...
If I could be a professor...
If I could be a writer... I'd have something more useful to write here.
If I could be a llama rider...
If I could be a bonnie pirate...
If I could be an astronaut...
If I could be a world famous blogger... what do you mean, if?
If I could be a justice on any one court in the world...
If I could be married to any one famous political figure...
If I could be a circus star...
If I could be a poet...
If I could be a musician... I'd be a drummer.
If I could be a chef...
If I could be a rodeo star...
If I could be a spin doctor... I'd be filled with doubt and self loathing.
I've just added one question.
I'll pass this on to Oscar, and we'll see if doctorvee wants it too. That's only two. One more applicant needed, apply below.
This is how it works. I will answer five of the questions below. In return, I will tag three people who will highlight, copy and paste into their blogs who will answer five questions below and pass it on to three other bloggers.
If I could be a scientist... I'd invent cool stuff to save the planet (and grow a big beard).
If I could be a painter... I'd paint the living room. It really needs freshening up.
If I could be a doctor...
If I could be a farmer...
If I could be a gardener...
If I could be a missionary...
If I could be a lawyer...
If I could be an athlete...
If I could be an innkeeper...
If I could be a professor...
If I could be a writer... I'd have something more useful to write here.
If I could be a llama rider...
If I could be a bonnie pirate...
If I could be an astronaut...
If I could be a world famous blogger... what do you mean, if?
If I could be a justice on any one court in the world...
If I could be married to any one famous political figure...
If I could be a circus star...
If I could be a poet...
If I could be a musician... I'd be a drummer.
If I could be a chef...
If I could be a rodeo star...
If I could be a spin doctor... I'd be filled with doubt and self loathing.
I've just added one question.
I'll pass this on to Oscar, and we'll see if doctorvee wants it too. That's only two. One more applicant needed, apply below.
Choo! Choo!
The gravy train currently departing from Number 10 complies entirely with the relevant regulations. It does go some way to explaining how the Blair's are going to pay off that enormous mortgage.
A Downing Street spokesman said:
Concerns over unethical behaviour? Our great leaders wife exploiting a grey area for money?
Not to worry. Just wheel out the Downing Street spokesman to make a denial based on a triviality only marginally connected to the controversial behaviour of Mrs Blair.
Nice work if you can get it.
A Downing Street spokesman said:
Mrs Blair's engagement has been arranged for some time. It is a private engagement and she is travelling independently of the prime minister's party. If she and the prime minister are in Washington at the same time it is a coincidence.Yet another conformation, as if it were needed, that a Downing Street spokesman can avoid the actual issue with breathtaking ease.
Concerns over unethical behaviour? Our great leaders wife exploiting a grey area for money?
Not to worry. Just wheel out the Downing Street spokesman to make a denial based on a triviality only marginally connected to the controversial behaviour of Mrs Blair.
Nice work if you can get it.
Activities for Insomniacs 1
What time wasting activities can be pursued when you can't sleep? As someone from Aberdeen I find it inadvisable to count sheep. Instead, I like to explore the wonders of the interweb in a semi-functioning shambolic meandering stroll. Snopes.com is one of those places which lends itself brilliantly to this activity.
Did you ever wonder whether eating carrots really does improve your eyesight? Snopes has the answer. It really surprised me. Who would have thought it? (Obviously that's a rhetorical question not aimed at those who already knew.)
What about those mad suicidal lemmings? Do you know what Darwin would have to say about them? Who cares when you can read all about those leaping lemmings on Snopes. Well I never.
Hours of educational fun to be had if you're suffering from insomnia. I'd imagine it might also be quite useful in the office, not that I'd encourage that sort of thing mind.
I've got an "If" meme I could be doing but it's just too late to attempt anything even marginally thought provoking right now. I will do it tomorrow.
Did you ever wonder whether eating carrots really does improve your eyesight? Snopes has the answer. It really surprised me. Who would have thought it? (Obviously that's a rhetorical question not aimed at those who already knew.)
What about those mad suicidal lemmings? Do you know what Darwin would have to say about them? Who cares when you can read all about those leaping lemmings on Snopes. Well I never.
Hours of educational fun to be had if you're suffering from insomnia. I'd imagine it might also be quite useful in the office, not that I'd encourage that sort of thing mind.
I've got an "If" meme I could be doing but it's just too late to attempt anything even marginally thought provoking right now. I will do it tomorrow.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




