Friday, July 15, 2005

We're All Still Watching

I'm a bit busy but I'd really like to blog this story. It's worth keeping an eye on. Not only did the G8 agreement not go far enough, it might not even go as far as was triumphantly announced.
Lets keep an eye on these fudging fudgers...

Apologists, Bush, Blair, and the Bombs

After some reflection, here are some thoughts on the bomb attacks in London.

The has been a lot of talk of responsibilty for the attacks. Jarndyce provides an excellent argument that the bombers alone are responsible for their action. I agree with this view but, as I posted in a comment, I feel that there is another aspect to be considered. This is really an attempt to expand on that comment.

The four men who killed at least 51 people in London on 7th July were entirely responsible for the terrible events of that day (ruling out the unlikely possibility that they were coerced). Those who may have encouraged them, aided them, and supplied them with explosives can also be considered responsible, but not directly. These were four men who made their own choices, and, whatever the outside influences, they alone are ultimately responsible for their actions. They carried the explosives onto the underground and onto a bus, and they killed those innocent people who just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. There is no doubt that they are absolutely responsible for this vile attack.

After reading the above you're probably thinking that I have let off lightly those who may have encouraged and supported the bombers, and you'd be right. Even though the bombers must take the blame for their own actions, there are others who's actions were part of the series of events which led to this tragedy. I'm sure we all agree that any aid given to the bombers is just as abhorent as the actions of the bombers themselves. They are also responsible for what happened, but that does not imply that the bombers themselves are not responsible. They chose to plant the bombs of their own free will and they are ultimately to blame for what happened. We can still say that the planners/handlers must also bear some responsiblity.

OK, I don't think any of the above is particularly controversial (feel free to disagree though). If we widen the potential influences acting on the bombers, it all gets much more difficult though.

Now I don't know exactly what motivated the bombers and I'll wager that you don't either. Were they fuelled by resentment over the UK's participation in the war in Iraq and the wider "war on terror"? No-one can really say and, given that they're now brown bread, I doubt we'll ever know for sure. All we can really say is that it is a possibilty. For the purposes of this post, lets assume that it was a motivating factor. I know it's a big assumption and acknowledge that this is speculation. For the record, I believe it's entirely plausible.

So, we're assuming that the "war on terror" was a motivating factor in the attacks. Would this make Bush and Blair responsible in any way for the bombings? Obviously they didn't participate directly in the attacks so they cannot be blamed in the way that the bombers can be. They were also not involved in the planning, preparation, or direct encouragement of the attacks so they do not share the responsibility of those who may have. So the answer is no?

Well, I'd argue that this isn't the case. This does not mean that I think Bush and Blair are equally morally responsible for the bombings. It does mean that their actions can be considered a motivating factor in the attack. If, as I do, you believe that the invasion of Iraq and the "war on terror" are themselves morally objectionable, and likely to cause more attacks such as these, then there is a burden of responsibility attached to the responses to these activities. They are not of the same degree, the deliberate intention of the bombers to kill indescriminately make their actions far more "wrong", but a responsibility still exists.

Here's an attempt at an analogy(it's not a strong point of mine but here goes). A man decides in a crisis that he must risk driving at great speed in an urban area in order to get his pregnant wife to hospital quickly (an ambulance would take 15 minutes to arrive). He knows that this is a dangerous activity but as he believes it is a matter of life and death he judges it is for the greater good. His neighbour advises him to wait, warning of the risks he will run if he attempts this journey but he is unconvinced. He sets off. His intentions are admirable but his actions may be unwise. He overtakes a boy racer who, feeling insulted at having been passed, is provoked into a high speed chase. The man is distracted as the boy racer pulls level, losses control, and causes both cars to crash into a crowd on the pavement, killing many, including the man's pregnant wife. So, who is responsible? The boy racer? Yes certainly. He is the direct cause of the accident. His senseless activities have resulted in tragedy. What about the man driving his wife to hospital? His intentions were good but his actions have resulted in many deaths. He must also take some share of the blame. His rash decision to drive dangerously was misjudged and he will certainly feel responsible for what happened. He'd been warned of the dangers but did not listen. He is not directly to blame, the boy racer must bear that burden, but, as he chose to be in the position which caused the accident, he has his own burden to bear. If he survives, there is a very real chance he will face prosecution for his actions. Murderer? No. Partly responsible? Yes, I think so.

I hope that helps explain my position. The terrorists were absolutely responsible for their own brutal and violent activites. But, I would argue that this is consistent with considering the invasion of Iraq and the "war on terror" a contributory factor in what happened on the 7th July. As such, and given that I believe the "war on terror" to be unjustified, heavy handed, provocative, and dangerous I believe the actions of Blair and Bush must be called into question. At it's heart is this question:
Are our leaders protecting us and the rest of the world in the best way possible?
For me the answer is no, and I must therefore conclude that Bush and Blair are also culpable in some sense for last Thursday's attacks. I make no apology for that.

Footnote: Robin Grant has more information on culpability.

Labour Win

It's not often I cheer when Labour win an election. In this case I'll make an exception. Congratulations to Mr Alok Agrawal for a resounding victory.

The result makes me proud to be British.
As for the BNP, lets send them back to whatever rock they crawled out from under.

Thursday, July 14, 2005

Expert Predictions

Some people might know that I've already written about terrorism expert David Capitanchik. He predicted that anti-capitalist activists might target Aberdeen's oil companies during the G8 summit. I didn't think it was very likely.

Well, now that the dust has settled it's possible to compare the facts with the predictions. I've kept an eye out in the local press and I have found one incident which might fit the bill. It was reported in the P&J on the 9th July.
Protesters have scrawled threatening graffiti across the north-east headquarters of an oil giant.Vandals who attacked Halliburton's Aberdeen base also smashed one of the panes on the glass-fronted building.Staff arrived at the Pitmedden Road site yesterday to find "Terrorism breeds murder" daubed across the entrance.
I'm sure David would claim this justifies his warnings. It's hardly carnage, anarchy, and chaos though. In fact, there's a lot worse vandalism than that every weekend in Aberdeen city centre. It wouldn't be right for me to draw any conclusions as to which of us was more accurate. I leave that for the reader to decide.

While we're on the subject, I've noticed David has made a number of other appearances in the media recently. He's quoted in an article in today's P&J but it's not online. That's OK though, because exactly the same article (I estimate it's 95% exactly the same words in exactly the same order) appeared in yesterday's Scotsman. (It's not the first time the P&J has reprinted an article from another newspaper. Apparently, it's quite common.)

Anyway, the article refers to US warnings that Al-Qaida could attack the Forth bridges using a bomb on a boat. David exhibits remarkable restraint, even going so far as to say "I think the Americans can go over the top sometimes." Sensible stuff.

David has also made many other media appearances. He is often decribed as "of Aberdeen University". Some examples:
David Capitanchik, of the University of Aberdeen
David Capitanchik, a terrorism expert at Aberdeen University
Professor David Capitanchik of Aberdeen University

In my previous post, I claimed that David had left the University of Aberdeen in 1993. I said he'd most recently worked for Robert Gordons University, but had retired. The references above caused me to doubt if I'd been right. I emailed the University of Aberdeen to ask if they could clarify David's position.
I received this reply:
Dear Mr Hamster,
Professor Capitanchik was employed by the University of Aberdeen some 12 years ago, and recently retired from The Robert Gordon University. I have had a look at their website and found a biography which you will find below [I've linked it instead].
I hope this helps
Regards...
This is, I believe, called fact checking. I'd always thought it was an important part of journalism. I'm not a professional though, and I've had no training in journalism so I might just have misunderstood the concept.

The Stonewall

Check out Scott McClellan's amazing performance as the US media tries to get to the bottom of Karl Rove's involvement in the Valerie Plame leak. It starts:
Q Does the President stand by his pledge to fire anyone involved in the leak of a name of a CIA operative?

MR. McCLELLAN: Terry, I appreciate your question. I think your question is being asked relating to some reports that are in reference to an ongoing criminal investigation. The criminal investigation that you reference is something that continues at this point. And as I've previously stated, while that investigation is ongoing, the White House is not going to comment on it.
There are a lot more answers like that.
Why has Scott suddenly become so shy? The President's pledge was made while the investigation was ongoing. Scott previously commented himself while the investigation was ongoing. Now that Karl Rove's name is attached to the leak, no-one at the White House wants to talk about it. Bloggers are certainly talking about it though.

Wednesday's press conference has more of the same.
Come in Karl, you're time is up.

Hurray for the "War on Terror"

In this post, I have conciously tried to be dispassionate. A lot of this will be old news to many people. I apologise if you are one of those people. I feel it needs to be said.

An accusation often leveled at those who oppose the "war on terror" is that we deny that a problem exists. It's a classic straw man argument. No sensible person denies that there is a threat from terrorist extremists. I've seen the images from New York and Bali and Madrid and London. They were horrible violent attacks on innocent civilians and there may well be more to come. A problem exists. No-one can sensibly deny it.
Another accusation is that we somehow support the terrorists by opposing the "war on terror". Again, a straw man argument. The last thing I want is for another attack to take place, or for one more innocent person to die. In fact, that's one of the reasons I started writing this blog. The threat exists and I believe that the policies of the US and the UK are magnifying that threat. That's why it is so important to have an honest and informed debate about the right way to respond to these threats. It's also why it's important to understand the following about how policy is currently shaped.

The Military Industrial Complex
Don't panic right wingers, there'll be no need for a TinFoil Hat. In it's simplest terms there is a parallel which illustrates the basic point I want to make. What's more, it is, to a large extent, an accepted right wing theory. It goes like this:
The public sector is inefficient. It creates it's own work. It constantly demands more resources than it actually needs. Jobs are created which are completely unnecessary. The incentives for efficiency are not strong. The academics will always need more money for "vital research" (climate change is all about this apparently), the civil service will always need more civil servants, and so on.*
Miltary organisations do this. The military is a public sector organization. There are many private compainies involved but the bills are almost exclusively paid by national governments. The US military is the master performer. In my time at University in the mid 90's, a course coordinator (and not a loony left one) told my tutorial group about a meeting he'd had with US military strategists. A General had quite candidly admitted that during the Cold War the US military had two sets of figures estimating the strength of the Soviet military. The first set, the real best guess figures, were for the top brass and the planners. The second set, the exaggerated figures, were for Congress. It was a case of "look how powerful the Soviets are. The US is under threat. Our budgets must be increased immediately". I can't find any links to back up this statement (research was never my strong point) but I've no reason to believe it isn't true. It fits nicely with the job creation theory.

Here's a warning from history on the subject:
In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the militaryindustrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist.

We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.
Dwight D. Eisenhower
That's right, that well known looney leftie Dwight D. Eisenhower. This was, of course, during the Cold War.

When the Cold War ended,the M.I.C. could no longer use the Soviet boogeyman to scare Congress into increasing military spending. US military spending fell slightly in the mid to late 90's. There were many calls from inside the US for more dramatic cuts to be enforced. Here's an example from the Clinton era:
Why the Cold War budget without the Cold War.

For the military, and the companies who supply them, the Cold War began to be thought of as a "golden age" of almost limitless funding. It seemed that they'd never see the like again.

But now they have. And it's all because of the "war on terror".
According to the 2005 yearbook published by Sipri, a well-respected think-tank on war and peace studies, the total spending on weapons in 2004 grew 8% to $1.035 trillion - the highest dollar value yet [global figures]. Adjusted for inflation, the figure falls just 6% below the all-time peak of spending in 1987-88, the last gasp of the Cold War...
The US alone accounted for 47% of the global total, mainly because of soaring spending on its "global war on terror".
BBC News
Just to be clear, I'm not absolutely not saying that the US military intentionally created the terrorist attacks we have seen. What I am saying is that there is an incentive to exaggerate the size of the threat and, crucially, increase the size of the military response. Think tanks such as the Project For a New American Century had been looking for a replacement for the Soviet threat and the terrorists delivered. For the M.I.C., the "war on terror" has all the best features of a second cold war:
  • It's prolonged.
  • It will not involve fighting a full "hot war". (You can't see the US invading North Korea or China for example).
  • There is a boogeyman to show Congress.
  • There is actually relatively little danger for US citizens.
What's more, the Bush administration's ability to resist pressure from the military industrial complex has been compromised by the extraordinary number of connections it has to the M.I.C. Right wing think tanks such as the PNAC (mentioned above), the Centre for Security Policy, and the National Institute for Public Policy are hugely influential. Have a look at the lists of names in these organizations. The revolving door is spinning like there's no tomorrow.

It seems that the Bush administration has chosen not to heed Eisenhower's warning. The threat is real, but it's being manipulated and exaggerated by those with an incentive to do just that. Sensible strategies have been sidelined in favour of hugely expensive, but misguided, military activities. In the end, the disproportionate military actions we have seen in the "war on terror", particularly in Iraq but elsewhere too, are driven by a strange breed of civil servant creating yet more jobs for the boys.

*I would argue that this is often a structural/management problem rather than ownership problem but that's a whole other argument.

Wednesday, July 13, 2005

Spin on This

The Guardian NewsBlog comments on the BBC's coverage of the attacks on London. They link to this Stephen Pollard piece for the Daily Mail. As I understand it, Mr Pollard not a stupid man. He is almost certainly aware that he is distorting a very difficult situation to promote his own agenda. This is why the reported reaction of one of the misquoted BBC journalists cheered me so much.

Let's get one thing straight. I believe in the BBC. It is internationally respected as an objective news broadcaster. I have found no better source of mainstream TV news. That doesn't mean its perfect. It can't be, its got humans in it. There are some stories I wish it would spend more time covering and they very occasionally make mistakes. All in all though, it does a bloody good job. This is partly why it's under attack from certain quarters.

Compare the BBC approach to this from Bill O'Reilly on Fox
(via a comment on the NewsBlog post) :
Once again, "Talking Points" urges all Americans to understand that people like Jane Fonda do damage to the country, even though the woman probably doesn't realize it. The only way to defeat worldwide terrorism is for the world to unite against it and overcome differences in support of that greater good.
Y'see, unlike the BBC, Bill doesn't want to present the facts and let the viewer make up their own mind. No, this is something else. He "urges all Americans" to support the party line. He states that opposing Bush administration policy is as good as helping the terrorists. He implies that anyone who speaks out against the Bush Doctrine is intellectually inferior. (And he throws in a little sexism just for good measure.)
Good work Bill, very Fair and Balanced (TM).

Still MP blogging

I've just finished a Bumper Anne Begg Post.
Edge of your seat dramas, face achingly funny anecdotes, unbearable tensions, and extreme emotional outbursts are just some of the things you'll not be able to find in my writing on Anne's activities. There are hopefully one or two marginally useful and/or amusing moments though.

Outstanding Links

An outstanding idea (via doctorvee). Good work.

An outstanding over-reaction. (via CY). Bad, scary, neo-con agenda driven work.

An outstanding piece of cowardice and stupidity. I see the powers that be have changed their minds after everyone started laughing and pointing. Very bad work.

And finally, an outstanding way to solve an old argument in a ridiculous, trivial, and completely pointless way. That's another three seconds of your life you'll never get back.
Ah well, at least it wasn't work.

Do Not Mention The Word!

Charles Kennedy had the audacity to mention Iraq yesterday. It's a cautious considered statement. He specifically says that the attacks should not be directly linked to the war.
"I am not here implying some causal link between Britain's involvement in Iraq and the terrible terrorist attacks in London last week. Not at all. The mass murderers who attacked London last week did not need Iraq as an excuse. The blame for the deaths in London falls firmly on their shoulders and on their shoulders alone."
But still, Downing Street is angry. Charles is apparently "naive" for even mentioning the word.
It's a thoughtcrime don't you know. Just who's side are you on Mr Kennedy?
*Sigh*

I don't know what the bombers were thinking. It's enormously unpleasant just to begin to try to understand what went on in their heads. I can't say whether Iraq pushed them over the edge, or whether they'd have carried out these attacks regardless.*

I do know that Blair and Bush have relentlessly linked Iraq to the "war" on terror. According to Downing Street, this link is no longer worthy of discussion. I'm assuming we'll hear no more from Bush or Blair about this non-existent link then?

*I am writing a post about my thoughts on the attacks and the continuing "war" on terror. I'm not going to rush it though.

Tuesday, July 12, 2005

Sick F*cks

Excuse my languange but this is fucking disgusting.

Nosemonkey has written a post on the subject of the BNP.
Go. And. Read It.

The BNP is becoming more and more influential in certain area's of British society. New Labour's abandonment of the working classes may be partly to blame. Whatever the reasons, it's a hugely troubling development.

I've been reading their website (no link, I've no intention of attracting a swarm of comment loons) and it's clear that they are intent on using the attacks for maximum propaganda value. What's more, much of this propaganda is very professionally presented. They know exactly what they're doing. They hide their racism behind rational sounding but emotive language. A snippet:
The London Massacre has tragically brought home to the entire country the terrible price ordinary people are now having to pay for the combination of the failed multi-cultural experiment, doubled up with Tony Blair's decision to involve Britain in a war that had nothing to do with us. The first step in finding a solution to any problem is to get the the roots of that problem.
And another:
War has come to our city streets. Blood is flowing. The time for action has come. Words are not enough. It is now time the British people were given back the power to protect themselves from those who have been allowed to enter our country and start wars against us and our way of life.
These people do not speak for me. They do not speak for the overwhelming majority of British citizens. They are nasty racist extremist bigots. As Katie says in the comments to Nosemonkey's post, lets start condemning them publicly and properly.

A Letter

There was a letter in yesterday's P&J (11/07, not online) which really took my breath away. Here it is in full:

G8 vandalism and violence
Sir, - Why don't the authorities arrest Sir Bob Geldof and his like for inciting vandalism and violence? I believe he is mostly responsible for the sickening malicious damage which happened around the G8 Gleneagles meeting, for which taxpayers will have to pay.
He stated unequivocally several times that the G8 countries are the world's richest. They are not, they are merely the world's most industrialised countries, with the biggest economies. The world's richest countries are not even at the G8. They are Bermuda, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Monaco, and Switzerland. Taxpayers and police have paid dearly for Geldof's error and he and the other ringleaders should be made to pay for the consequences.
[Name and address removed to protect the ignorant]

It's difficult to even begin to comment on this letter. How is it possible to be so misguided so often in such a short letter?

Stop the planet please, I want to get off.

Monday, July 11, 2005

The SPBR

A wee while back I mentioned the Scottish Political Blog Review initiated by Stuart from Independence. Well, things are starting to progress and the first review is to be published shortly.

Go here and read this for more details (especially if you're in Scotland and you write a blog about politics). Go to it people.

Late Night Photo Chopping

Here are some pictoral messages for the worlds most elusive man.

Chicken!
Run away!
Yellow!
Brave Sir Osama!

As it's the middle of the night early in the morning my ability to judge the worth of these is somewhat diminished but I think the message is clear enough.

On a serious note it's probably not sensible to attribute blame for the London Bombings until the necessary investigations have been carried out. I think we can all agree that Osama is a chicken shit bastard though.

Cosmetically Challenging

I've made a new banner for the blog. I really haven't decided if it's an improvement.
I do like to mess around with the Gimp though. Free PS software? Splendid!

I've also added a wee bit of self promotion to the "about me" section in the sidebar. Well, I just couldn't resist.

Update - more random thoughts.
It looks like T in the Park rocked as usual. Nice weather too (which is much less usual). I haven't been for a few years now but I've got lots of good, if rather vague memories of Balado. Next year I'm going.
I've been watching the highlights on BBC 2 Scotland. Green Day headlined the main stage on Sunday but they wouldn't allow the BBC to film any of their set. This is the first time I've ever heard of this happening. Apparently it's because they've got a DVD coming out shortly. Tossers American Idiots.

The Press and Journal website has been misbehaving this week. The search function returns a "null" result for every search I've tried. In the interest of scientific research I wonder if someone else could try a couple of searches and let me know if they have the same problem.

I did say was going to post something about me and my failure to attend the G8 protests but I'm just not in the mood for baring my soul this weekend. I will get round to it soon though.

Another update - did I really write "random thoughts" in this post?
I'll get me coat...
Here's an extra link (via Boing Boing) by way of apology. London laughs in the face of danger.

Sunday, July 10, 2005

The Good Bits

Tim Worstall has prepared Britblog Roundup 21 for your reading pleasure. Lots of good stuff this week.

Curious Leakage

The BBC reports that a "pull out" plan for Iraq has been leaked to the Mail on Sunday (via CY). Here's the article in the Mail on Sunday.
A secret paper written by Defence Secretary John Reid for Tony Blair reveals that many of the 8,500 British troops in Iraq are set to be brought home within three months, with most of the rest returning six months later.
The leaked document, marked Secret: UK Eyes Only, appears to fly in the face of Mr Blair and President Bush's pledges that Allied forces will not quit until Iraq's own forces are strong enough to take control of security...
The Ministry of Defence last night confirmed the leaked document was genuine. Mr Reid said: "This is but one of a number of papers produced over recent months covering various scenarios. We have made it plain we will stay in Iraq for as long as is needed. No decisions on the future of UK forces have been taken.
Interesting.
And as Justin points out, it's a curious time for a leak of this sort. No decision has been taken but the idea has been leaked to the media by someone. A government toe in the water of public opinion?
I seem to remember that the House of Commons was used for holding debates like this at one time. I could be wrong.

Anyway, here's the memo in full.
There seems to be very little mention of the quality of life of ordinary Iraqi's. I'm sure it is the number one priority though. The Defence Secretary summarizes US pressure:
US political military thinking is still evolving. But there is a strong US military desire for significant force reductions to bring relief to overall US commitment levels.
Mr Reid also gives us an insight into the important factors weighing on his own mind.
Looking further ahead, we have a clear UK military aspiration to hand over to Iraqi control...
This in turn should lead to a reduction in the total level of UK commitment in Iraq...
This should lead to an estimated halving in the costs which fall to the reserve, around £1 billion per annum currently.
Money money money, must be funny...
Ordinary Iraqi's are the number one priority though.

Saturday, July 09, 2005

Pastor Get Medieval

A Peterhead pastor has been found guilty of attacking a car with a baseball bat. He was provoked by a gang of youths into eventually smashing the windscreen while they were still in the car. It is a very rare occassion when I'm tempted to quote from the Bible. How about I quote from Pulp Fiction instead?
Ezekiel 25:17.
The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the inequities of the selfish and the tyranny of evil men. Blessed is he who, in the name of charity and good will, shepherds the weak through the valley of the darkness. For he is truly his brother's keeper and the finder of lost children. And I will strike down upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger those who attempt to poison and destroy my brothers. And you will know I am the Lord when I lay my vengeance upon you.
The pastor has been forced to resign his position at the Peterhead Pentecostal Christian Zion Tabernacle Church.
*Ahem* Sounds like a perfectly sensible organisation to me.

So, does anyone think that the baseball ball weilding badass pastor is representative of all Christians? Anyone think this demonstrates that Christianity is an inherently violent religion?

Inside the Ring of Steel

Make Poverty History have responded to the G8 Communique. Here's an exclusive behind the scenes look at what really went on inside the Gleneagles Hotel*.

Inside the G8

*This sentence actually has a very tenuous connection to the truth. Apologies for yet another of my photoshop experiments. This one actually took a wee while so I had to share it.

Edit: Smaller version to fit the page. Larger version here if you're interested.

Friday, July 08, 2005

Reaction

Nosemonkey has news of a pledge.
Anyone who's in the London area will probably want to sign it.

Some other reactions:
Oscar Wildebeest.
Green Fairy.
Kathy F.

Update
Bloggerheads on reaction from the Murdoch empire. You want evil...