Friday, July 22, 2005

Moral Equivalence

Now the excrement is really hitting the blade driven nitrogen/oxygen agitation device.

Let's take a step back. There's been a lot of talk in the UK since July 7th about moral equivalence. I've been thinking about that today. Here's a half baked thought on the subject.

It is not possible to justify the actions of the terrorists who killed 52 people on that day in London. The deliberate targetting of civilians in this way is absolutely unacceptable whatever their motivations. The "root causes" of these actions are irrelevant. The fact that they believed that they had a just cause is also irrelevant. Even if they genuinely did have a just cause, the actions themselves can never be justified.
Why do we say that?
It's because they deliberately killed 52 innocent people. This is simply unacceptable. End of argument. I agree with this in it's entirety. It's rock solid.

What happens if we extend that argument to include the actions of nation states though?
An example.
In 1945, the US government ordered the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. According to Wikipedia, these actions killed 120,000 people immediately and around 240,000 in the aftermath. They were primarily civilians.

The deliberate targetting of civilians in this way is absolutely unacceptable, whatever their motivations. The "root causes" of these actions are irrelevant. The fact that they believed that they had a just cause is also irrelevant. Even if they genuinely did have a just cause, the actions themselves can never be justified.
Why do we say that?
It's because they deliberately killed 300,000 (my estimate) innocent people. This is simply unacceptable. End of argument. I agree with this in it's entirety. It's rock solid.

What's wrong with this argument then? I genuinely can't see a flaw as I write this. I accept that there might be one but what is it?
It seems to me that nation state violence is acceptable just because it is. Or rather, just because we say it is. So is it really the action itself we find so appalling, or are we only appalled when these actions are aimed at us?
Just a thought.

Owzat!

Today I shall be mostly watching the cricket. I only mention it because I'm a Scotsman and the only one I know who'll be cheering England on.
Not that I won't extract the urine if they get drubbed mind you.
For the record, I do hope they win the wee urn thingie.
That is all.

Thursday, July 21, 2005

The Ice Cream Suicides

This is part two in my attempt to "prove" that the invasion of Iraq has increased the threat of worldwide terrorist attacks. In part one, I arrived at these figures for worldwide terrorist attacks using US government statistics:
2001: 346
2002: 198
2003: 190 208
2004: 3,192

As I said, these figures don't prove anything on their own. We need to make some assumptions about them if they are to be useful.

First, are they consistent, objective, accurate figures? Well, the straightforward answer is no, they are not. They are only the "judgement" of the US government. I'm going to assume that these figures are representative enough to be useful. Can this assumption be challenged by those with a different view of the invasion? Well, it'd be difficult for the US government to challenge it. US officials insisted today that "our numbers are not representative". No, I think it's a pretty solid assumption.

So now, we are left with a huge rise in worldwide terrorist acts in 2004. In fact, the 2004 figure is over 9 times as high as the 2001 figure. I suspect most people think that 2001 was the worst year in the history of terrorism. Just to be clear, according to the US government in 2004 there were 9 times as many attacks as in 2001.

Suicide and Ice Cream

(Another blogger used this example a while back, but I'm afraid I can't remember who it was.)
It's important for me to understand why these figures on their own still don't prove anything. Here's why.
In Scotland, it appears that an increase in ice cream sales causes an increase in the suicide rate.
Of course that isn't actually true but if you look at the figures, it might seem that it is. In Scotland, ice cream sales increase in the summer and decrease in the winter. This is pretty obvious. Suicide rates also increase in the summer and decrease in the winter. [Link for doubters]
More Ice Cream = More Suicide

Now that's clearly a nonsense and we see why. The seasons are affecting suicide rates. This coincides with an increase in ice cream sales, but there is no causal link. Ice cream doesn't make people suicidal (to my knowledge anyway).

So, at this stage we've just got the figures showing the huge rise in terrorist attacks in 2004. There may be only a coincidental relationship between the invasion of Iraq and this increase. Can I assume that this isn't a coincidental relationship?

Let's try some tests. Is there another explanation for the increase which doesn't involve Iraq? Well, here are my thoughts.
1. It was going to happen anyway.
This is a difficult argument to counter. It's also a difficult argument to prove. In the end, we have to make a judgement here. Without Iraq, would the number of terrorist attacks have increased ninefold in 2004. I say no. I think we can discard the idea that an unprecedented 3,192 terrorist attacks would have occurred in 2004 even if the coalition had not invaded Iraq. It seems self evident.

2. Another independent factor coincidentally occurred around the same time as the invasion.
My question is, what was it? I suppose it could be argued that just fighting the "war" on terror has caused the terrorists to conduct more attacks. But that rather supports my point that the "war" on terror and invasion have increased the number of attacks. If this is the case, we've surely got to ask if there had been a better way to catch these people before they became active. If they were content to bide their time we might have caught them by more subtle means. Why start a "war"? To flush them out? That's not a very good way to protect the 28,433 people the terrorists killed in 2004. Wouldn't it have been better to get the CIA, SIS, Mossad and other such organisations to track them down quietly while they pottered about thinking they were safe? If the intention was to "flush them out" it's an intention which has killed a great many people who would otherwise be alive.

There may be other independent factors but I can't think of any at the moment. Any other suggestions for what caused the 2004 figure to be so high?

Now, let's look at it from another angle. Can I construct a plausible explanation as to why the invasion of Iraq caused terrorist attacks to increase? This is from a comment I made in an earlier post:
3 or 4 years ago... there were a few small groups of nutjobs and a whole lot of people who'd heard their hate filled rhetoric but had rejected it. Then came the "war" on terror, and the invasion of Iraq. Suddenly, the hate filled rhetoric of the nutjobs starts to get through to more people. "Look, they have invaded a sovereign Islamic country without provocation" the extremists will say. And they'll go on "these evil imperialists truly do hate all muslims. You who had not believed me before, come now and see by their actions. They will not rest until every Muslim bows to their false god..." This is continued indefinitely, and then repeated indefinitely just for good measure.
These hypothetical extremist's words are a distortion, but a powerful one. So, does this seem plausible? Again, to me it is self evident that this has occurred many times since March 2003 . Many people have now accepted the extremists rhetoric who would otherwise have rejected it.

Is this speculation? Yes, it is. It's not easy to understand* what motivates someone to accept an extremist position. It is the most crucial factor in preventing it happening more often. Is this the best explanation we've got for the 3,192 terrorist attacks in 2004? I say it is.

I see that this doesn't "prove" my position because we've had to make some assumption on the way. I believe that they are all reasonable assumptions. Is it persuasive? I really don't know.

*Be warned: Any attempts to redefine the word "understand" in this context to instead mean "sympathise" will be treated harshly. I may understand why someone would do it but I won't be sympathetic. Knowledge is power. Always.

On Objectivity

After what happened in London today, understanding terrorism is more important than ever.

The ever intelligent doctorvee made an interesting point in a though splurge a couple of days back.
I was against the war in Iraq for a variety of reasons, one of which was that I thought that it would increase the threat of terrorism. The thing about the London bombings is that it gave both sides of the increasingly tedious pro- / anti-war debate more ammunition. Those who were in favour of the Iraq invasion say, “Look, we told you so, terrorists are everywhere, so we need to go get ‘em!” Those who were against say, “We told you so, Iraq increased the threat of terrorism.”
I've been thinking about this for a couple of days now. I feel very strongly about the stupidity of the invasion of Iraq and I struggle to understand those who argue that it was useful in the "war" on terror. To me, it seems self evident that Iraq has been a huge mistake. I genuinely do not think this is a matter of opinion. I thought I'd attempt to examine, understand and explain why I feel this way. This is pretty long winded, but please try to bear with it.

So, if I'm going to "prove" that Iraq has increased the terrorist threat, the first thing I need are some salient facts. What facts do I need? As a starting point, I think I need the statistics for worldwide terrorist attacks before and after the invasion. This won't be a "proof" but it will be
a first step. More on that later. Lets try to collect some facts first.

OK, what's the first problem you face when counting terrorist attacks? Hopefully, regular readers already understand that the first problem is that it's very difficult to define terrorism.
Terrorism is a value judgement. It's ugly, it's frustrating, it's
counter-intuitive, but it's true nevertheless (please have the courtesy to read the linked post and attached comments if you'd like to comment on that. Thanks.) So, how can I get some objective facts on this? Well, I happened to remember that the CIA has been publishing statistics on worldwide terrorist attacks for many years. Let's use the CIA figures. The definition they use will be open to interpretation, but if it's been applied consistently it should provide a reasonable set of figures.

Here's where my travels took me when trying to track down these figures on the interweb. Some of this is yesterday's news so apologies any of it covers old ground.

First, let's see if we can find the CIA's "objective definition".
How do you define terrorism?
The Intelligence Community is guided by the definition of terrorism contained in Title 22 of the US Code, Section 2656f(d):
—The term “terrorism” means premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents, usually intended to influence an audience.
"Guided by"? Well, that's hardly objective. We'll just have to make do and assume they're being consistent in their judgements.
On April 29th, 2004, the CIA published their figures for 2001, 2002 and 2003.
There were 190 acts of international terrorism in 2003, a slight decrease from the 198 attacks that occurred in 2002, and a drop of 45 percent from the level in 2001 of 346 attacks. The figure in 2003 represents the lowest annual total of international terrorist attacks since 1969.
The lowest annual total since 1969? That's interesting. These figures have a note attached.
Note: Most of the attacks that have occurred during Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom do not meet the longstanding US definition of international terrorism because they were directed at combatants, that is, US and Coalition forces on duty. Attacks against noncombatants, that is, civilians and military personnel who at the time of the incident were unarmed and/or not on duty, are judged as terrorist attacks.
You'll recall that there was a period after the "mission accomplished" declaration when there was relative stability in Iraq (there was looting, but not terrorism). This was followed by a rise in attacks on coalition soldiers. The targetting of civilians didn't begin in earnest until later.
Anyway, these figures were "updated" on 22nd June, 2004.
There were 208 acts of international terrorism in 2003...
It seems that 2003 is no longer the year with the lowest number of terrorist attacks since 1969. These, also have the same note attached as before.

Right, we have three figures.
2001: 346
2002: 198
2003: 190 208

What I really want now are the CIA figures for 2004. They should be available judging by the fact that the 2003 figures were published and then revised by June 2004.
Well, you'd think that but:
April 16th, 2005
The State Department has decided to stop publishing an annual report on international terrorism after the government's top terrorism center concluded there were more terrorist attacks in 2004 than in any year since 1985, the first year the publication covered.
Seems that for the first time in 20 years, the CIA. Strange. I wonder why that is? Here's the stated reason in the next paragragh:
Several U.S. officials defended the abrupt decision, saying the methodology used by the National Counterterrorism Center may have been faulty, including incidents that might not have been terrorism.
So, there may be a problem with consistency. Of course, if "terrorism is not a value judgement" this is difficult to understand. Fortunately, I think we now understand that such a statement is total bolloc fails to accurately describe the concept of terrorism.
So, I'm stuck?

Well, not quite.
The 2004 figures from the National Counterterrorism Center are discussed in this transcript from a discusion on a New York radio station.
BOB GARFIELD: According to the statistics that the National Counterterrorism Center has provided, the 600-some number doesn't even count any of the insurgent attacks in Iraq, which the administration explicitly describes as terrorism.
JONATHAN LANDAY: That's absolutely true, and the other significant point of that is that almost 300 of those incidents are from the Indian-controlled part of Kashmir - terrorist attacks staged by Muslim extremist groups who are backed by Pakistan, which is supposedly a partner in the administration's war on terrorism. So it doesn't, to some people, look too kosher.
So, it looks like the figure is over 600. Approximately. That's not very satisfactory. And from one source only, and one I've never heard of until now. We can do better.
Let's try this from the Times, 7th July, 2005. (Just in case: Put your Tinfoil Hat away and don't be stupid. I'm not joking. Think about it.)
THERE were nearly 3,200 terrorist attacks worldwide last year, the Bush Administration said yesterday, using a broader definition that increased fivefold the number of incidents that Washington had previously tallied for 2004.
In figures published in April, the US State Department said that there were 651 significant international terror incidents, with more than 9,000 victims.
But under the newer, less-stringent definition of terrorism, which counts domestic attacks without an international element, the National Counterterrorism Centre (NCTC) reported 3,192 attacks worldwide, with 28,433 people killed, wounded or kidnapped.
3,192 attack worldwide in 2004. Pardon me but fuck, that's a lot of attacks. How many were there in 2001 again? I'll save you a scroll back up, it was 346. Of course these figures are not strictly comparable, since a "broader definition" was used for the 2004 figures. Anyone still thinking about that Pollard statement? Here's a quote from the Times on that:
Asked how the NCTC distinguishes between freedom fighters and terrorists, Mr Brennan said that the centre’s database is not “black and white and perfect”.
Not "black and white"? Shades of great then. At least he admits it, unlike some poor misguided individuals.
Anyway, the best figures we've got are these.
2001: 346
2002: 198
2003: 190 208
2004: 3,192

Of course this doesn't prove anything. As this post is already rather long, I'm going to split it in two.
The next installment, "The IceCream Suicides", is coming soon!

Thribbage

Alas, poor Scotty,
You cannae take any more,
Captain,
You have one more voyage,
To boldly undertake,
To rest at the Final Frontier,
Which seems rather apt,
To me.

Wednesday, July 20, 2005

In Support in the Inane

I'm trying to write a post about terrorism, definitions, and Iraq. It's not fully formed yet but I've decided to stop thinking about it till tomorrow. Instead, lets have some inane trivial nonsense.

Earlier today my stat report highlighted this search result. Number 7 out of about 19,600,000 for "go*d vio**nce (no further though, thanks all the same). A happy day, I'm sure you'll agree.
I think I vaguely see how this has happened. I blame the Crazy Frog. Ooh, I hate that frog! He makes me so mad...

Perhaps a bit of this [caution: may contain comedy gore] will calm me down a bit.
Do you know, I do believe it does. Turn the sound volume up for maximum satisfaction.

Levels of Threat

A JTAC report has been leaked which explains the government decision to lower the threat level from "severe defined" to "substantial" weeks before the London bombings. This is slightly embarrassing for the government.

The JTAC report does say:
"Events in Iraq are continuing to act as motivation and a focus of a range of terrorist related activity in the UK"
This is obviously not something Blair wants us to hear, especially as it comes from his own security services. That's not actually the point I want to make here though.

The Safety Elephant said something which appeared in the Observer on the 8th of July.
Mr Clarke said: "The overall security level was reduced and we felt that was the correct situation. Now, of course, we look back on that and consider exactly what the situation was, but I think it's important to indicate that even if the threat level had been at a higher level than it actually was yesterday, that doesn't mean we would have been more successful in identifying these perpetrators before the event took place."
Right. Have a wee think about that. The Scotsman article, linked above, summarizes his position like this:
Charles Clarke, the Home Secretary, and the Metropolitan Police insisted in the immediate aftermath of the atrocities that the lowering of the threat level had no practical effect on security precautions taken.
Hmm. That does rather open up the question of what the threat level is actually for, wouldn't you say? If the government increases the threat level, "that doesn't mean we would have been more successful in identifying these perpetrators before the event took place." So it seems that the threat level isn't about increasing or decreasing the level of security in the country.

What is it for then?
Could it be that the government threat level scale is nothing more than an exercise in manipulating public opinion? If it's not about security, I can't think of anything else it can usefully achieve. You could argue that a raised threat level encourages the public to be more vigilant thus helping to prevent attacks. But Clarke has explicitly said that an increased threat level wouldn't have provided increased security so that argument seems flawed.

Is this actually an admission by Clarke that the government threat level warnings are nothing more than political propaganda? Answers on a postcard...

One last thing. I've been watching the government response to the London attacks and it's been pretty professionally handled. I'd say it has almost certainly been planned and rehearsed. I'm not saying that's wrong, in fact it's probably emminently sensible. It is worth bearing in mind when assessing the government responses to the attacks though.

Tuesday, July 19, 2005

This is Rather Good

Here's some light relief from a flipping Ninja (via Bloggerheads). Loving the Sax solo.

Don't know quite why but this one cracks me up every time I hear it. I should warn you, you'll be singing this for days. Definitely worth it though.

Failure is not an Option

What on earth are they thinking?

You will not fail! Instead you will achieve "deferred success".
That's certainly helps explain a great deal about my life. I am currently experiencing a period of deferred success. Excellent. I feel much better for knowing that.

I'm normally reasonably open minded, but I'm afraid I'm on the side of the red tops on this one.
As we say up here in Aberdeen, "wise up, eh?"

Edit/update
As Oscar Wildebeest quite rightly points out in the comments to this post, this story is isn't quite as I've portrayed it:
It's about saying to schoolchildren, "look, you haven't achieved the desired standard, but with some more work and more time, you could achieve it." That seems OK to me. Come on, this is egalitarianism in action! Isn't that what all we progressive liberals are supposed to be in favour of? No, I don't have my sarcastic hat on - I mean this.
It's a fair point. My apologies to all concerned.

This isn't to excuse my laziness, but I've just read the BBC page again.
Teachers say no-one should 'fail' School tests
"Deferred success" should replace the idea of failure for low-achieving pupils, a teachers' organisation will hear at its annual conference.
Hang on a minute. Is this yet more indisputable, undeniable, incontrovertible proof that the BBC has a conservative bias? Look at the headline. And talk about an unsympathetic opening sentence. This is clearly yet another attempt by the conservative BBC to broadcast their odious right-wing propaganda. And they claim to be neutral! Disgusting, it is! Just the other day I watched a programme all about interior decorating and increasing the value of your house. They never once mentioned that consumerism doesn't make you happy. I tell you, it was like reading the Daily Mail...*

*This may not be my actual opinion.

Things Can Only Get Better

The Pottery Barn Rule: You break it, you own it.
Colin Powell, 2002. Cited by Bob Woodward, Plan of Attack
The Iraq Body Count organisation has released a new report on civilian casualties in Iraq since March 2003. It makes for grim reading. Here's a summary of their findings and here's the full report (pdf).
The civilian death toll
24,865 civilians have been reported killed, almost all of them as a direct result of violence, between 20March 2003 and 19 March 2005. The population of Iraq is approximately 25,000,000, meaning that one in every thousand Iraqis has been violently killed since March 2003.
(Full report. Fact Sheet 1.)
1 in every 1000 Iraqi's has died violently since the invasion. That's more than 400 times as many people as were tragically killed by the London bombers. Nearly 25,000 scenes as graphic and disturbing as this one. I have to warn readers of the graphic nature of this image because 1 in 1000 readers won't ever have seen anything like this in their lives. In Iraq, something like this has *happened* to 1 in every 1000 civilians in two short years.

But things *are* getting better, right?
When did they do their killing?
Deaths caused by anti-occupation forces, crime and unknown agents have shown a steady rise over the entire period.
(Fact Sheet 2.)
The facts are that the violence has been getting steadily worse. There is no way to spin this. It's getting worse. Violence in Iraq has been steadily increasing since the invasion. Protecting the lives of Iraqi civilians is a legal obligation under international law. The "coalition of the willing" is failing in it's legal responsibility.

That's not to say that the terrorists or insurgents (or whatever you want to call them) are not responsible for their own actions. They are. I condemn their actions in the strongest possible terms.

But the fact is that the US and UK governments have created the conditions in Iraq for this to happen. Leave aside the debate as to whether the invasion itself was right or wrong. Can Bush or Blair honestly say that they have handled the post-invasion period in a competent manner?

I've never been opposed to the removal by force of Saddam Hussein. As I've said before, it's good that he is gone. What I am opposed to is the fact that this invasion was badly planned, badly executed, and based on more than one false premise. Now we are left with "saving Iraqi's from Saddam" as the only justification for the war. This is a noble cause, but only if we are able to provide a safer alternative. Sadly, the "coalition of the willing" does not appear at any time to have had a suitable plan to bring this about. Does anyone remember when we were told the US and UK liberators were going to be greeted in the streets of Baghdad with cheers and flowers? Instead, they are greeted with suicide bombers and RPGs.This misjudgement is the real tragedy of the invasion of Iraq.

And I'm not one of those people who thinks we should pull out of Iraq now that it's all got FUBAR. We've broken it, now we own it. What is needed is a fundamental rethink of how we can provide security in Iraq.

In the UK, the first step in that process must be for Blair to resign. He committed us to the war without a workable plan as to how to end it. This, despite the many warnings that the situation would develop just as it has. He doesn't accept that he's made any mistakes when the evidence is that he has made many.
Blair doesn't seem to think he's got a case to answer. Does anyone think the grieving relatives of the 24, 865 known Iraqi casualties agree?

Fear the Power of the Interweb

It's very late/early (depending on your point of view) so it seems as good a time as any to congratulate the NO2ID campaign for reaching 10,000 pledges (and counting). That really is an impressive achievement. It's not for me to tell anyone what to do but sign up! sign up!! sign up!!!

Anyway, the campaign's success can be partly attributed to a splendid interweb campaign. That there interweb is indeed a powerful weapon in the fight against tyranny.

While were on the subject, here's episode 243 in my attempts to generate a meme. Safety Elephant?* Anyone? C'mon, what's better than a vaguely amusing but utterly futile gesture?

*Obviously, I'm not claiming to have invented the phrase. I'm afraid I'm in ignorance as to the identity of the originator of the tag and am therefore unable to cite and congratulate the person responsible. Good work though.

Monday, July 18, 2005

The "War" on Terror

"There are no terrorists in Iraq" says Defence Secretary John Reid.
Or have I misunderstood that?

Terrorism Defined

This could be considered another slice of half-baked philosophy pie except I actually do have a reasonable idea what I'm talking about here (yes, for a change). Without wishing to sound like an arse, I have studied terrorism at University so I do know a fair bit about it (not that I'm claiming to be an expert mind you). Now that I've alienated you with my feeble attempts at intellectual snobbery, lets get on with it.

Last week I wrote about the reaction to the BBC's decision not to use the word terrorist. Doctorvee spotted an amusingly straplined Nick Cohen article on the subject. Now the point I made is that terrorism is actually very difficult to define. I'd be very surprised if Pollard didn't know this when he wrote:
But terrorism is not a value judgement. It is recognised as a crime against humanity under international law. Professor Norman Geras defines it as “the deliberate targeting of civilians with a view to killing and maiming them and if possible in large numbers”.
I'm afraid he's being disingenuous (is about the kindest thing I can think to write here). Now I don't really want to make the fellow look foolish but lets start with the definition he gives. Terrorism is "the deliberate targeting of civilians with a view to killing and maiming them and if possible in large numbers". It seems reasonable enough. So was the bombing of Hiroshima a terrorist attack? Was it a crime against humanity? I'd argue that it could be considered the former and it's certainly the latter. Lots of people will agree, but lots of people will disagree too. They might argue that it saved many more lives than were lost, for example. We have to agree that it was the "deliberate targeting of civilians with a view to killing and maiming them and if possible in large numbers" because that is undeniably what it was. But do we agree that it was terrorism? No, because it's a value judgement. So this definition can be discarded. For many people, it's possible for an action to fullful the criteria but not qualify as a terrorist act.

So, lets look at some other definitions.
The Compact Oxford English Dictionary keeps it short (as you'd expect).
Terrorist:
a person who uses violence and intimidation in the pursuit of political aims.
Derivatives: Terrorism.
Well, that one is obviously rubbish. Every soldier who ever fought a war is guilty of that. Every PM or President who ever ordered war is guilty of that. Discard. Next.

The Cambridge Dictionary of American English.
violent action for political purposes
Every war ever. Discard. Next.

Encyclopedia Britannica.
Systematic use of violence to create a general climate of fear in a population and thereby to bring about a particular political objective.
The US carpet bombing of Hanoi, was that terrorism? What about Dresden? Value judgement. Discard. Next.

Dictionary.com
The unlawful use or threatened use of force or violence by a person or an organized group against people or property with the intention of intimidating or coercing societies or governments, often for ideological or political reasons.
Good effort. "Unlawful force" makes this more precise. So, was the war in Iraq legal? I, and many other people, say no, our great leader says yes. If it wasn't legal the invasion of Iraq would qualify under this definition. Smells like another value judgement to me. Discard. Next.

Oh, this is futile. I've got an idea. Why don't I check to see what Wikipedia has to say. It's created democratically so it should have the most refined definition.
Wikipedia.
The word "terrorism" is controversial and has many definitions, none of which are universally accepted.
Right. So that's pretty much exactly what I've been saying then (although I see the article is disputed, must be a disagreement over value judgements). You see why I find it very difficult to understand why Pollard says "But terrorism is not a value judgement". If there was one definition of terrorism we could all agree on then this might be true. As it is, he's peddling an untruth to further his own agenda. If you really want to inform people about terrorism the first thing you should do is explain how difficult it is to define.

Just to be absolutely clear, my point is not whether the London bombers can be called terrorists. I'd say the bombers can be called terrorists by almost any definition you care to come up with. The point is that a word with no clearly agreed definition isn't actually a very useful word. It might be a fantastic word for poetry but it's not that useful for reporting the news. The BBC prefers to use the word bomber because it does have a clearly agreed definition.

If you disagree with me, here's a little challenge. Provide a definition of terrorism which isn't controversial. My comments are open for sensible debate . I'd advise against employing the standard "non-state actors" gambit though. It opens up the possibilty that a suicide bomber directly employed by a state cannot, by definition, be a terrorist. That surely wouldn't be right, would it?
(I appear to have accidentally taken handfull of pompous pills today. Sorry, but I can't think of a better way to phrase that last paragraph. I'm actually quite modest once you get to know me, it's true, honestly it is...)

Update
Tim Ireland takes a wider view of the Pollard article and describes what he sees. Definitely worth reading.

Edit: Spelling, see comment. Doh...

Seconds Out - Roundup 1

As promised, the first ever SPBR roundup is now available for your perusal. My advice is to peruse to your leisure. It's all interesting stuff (but then I would say that). Anyway, peruse away.

Sunday, July 17, 2005

Behind the Mask?

Robin Grant has posted about a new initiative called Unite Against Terror. Whilst it's objectives appear to be entirely honourable, I'm not altogether convinced it's exactly what it purports to be. There is no mention of who is behind the site. A commentor is pretty certain it's directly connected to the Labour party.
So, is it astroturfing or a genuine initiative unconnected to the Labour Party?
I think I'll withhold judgement (and signature) until smarter people than myself have checked it out.
If anyone does have any opinions, useful links, or information on Unite against Terror, I'd be most obliged if they could let me know.

Health Advice

I urge you to read this (if you're an adult anyway).

Read it? OK, now click on my permalink.


Via Bill who has more information here.
Did you believe it? No, I'm sure none of my readers are that gullible.
Rather amusing though.

Lazy Sunday

It's another lazy Sunday afternoon. It's time to line up a cold drink and delve into the wonder that is Tim Worstall's 22nd Britblog roundup.

I'm still making my way through it but I just had to mention one post in which The Antagonist really gets very confused about the events of 7th July. I don't mean to sound unkind but this does seem to be the perfect illustration of the TinFoil Hat phenomenon. My friendly advice to the Antagonist would be to stop posting for a few days. Try to relax, go for some long walks, think nice thoughts about those around you, perhaps read some Nosemonkey or Chicken Yoghurt or Bloggerheads posts. These three almost always have something intelligent to say. But please stop posting that particular conspiracy theory. It's clearly a nonsense and it's doing no-one any favours.

Random Fluctuations in the Mysterious Interweb Flux Capacitor Continuum

I've had at least one comment vanish today. Haloscan has been acting strangely this week but this is the first time I've noticed this happening. Bookdrunk has had the same problem. If you've left a comment and it's disappeared, it's Haloscan what done it. So far, I haven't deleted a single comment. Apologies if you've written something which has been swallowed up.

If this shoddy service continues I shall be forced to consider allowing another company to provide a free commenting service. It seems to be working OK at the moment.

Saturday, July 16, 2005

A Reminder

There's still time to nominate posts for this. The first roundup will be posted on Monday. We've already had some good submissions. Lets be having some more.

Furry Mammals

As it's the weekend, here's something a bit different. In a variation on a theme meme I bring you not cat or kitten but ferret blogging. There's a photo in the deadwood version too.
I. Want. One. Of. These.

Sadly, I fear the cat (ok, a bit of cat blogging) wouldn't be impressed. Don't send me one.